Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Long Island:
Brilliant bar with original features and modern eclectic bar list. We just went in for a drink but were not disappointed, my White Negroni was excellent. Special mention regarding the decor. All original decor from around 1950. Without sounding pretentious- post Art deco? View all feedback.
What Dean C doesn't like about Long Island:
$22 for a disgusting burger? I feel ripped off. No exaggeration a Big Mac is better value. And I can’t believe how busy it was, and seeing all the burgers come out of the kitchen. It was a tiny tasteless thing with gloppy sauce. And a draft beer was in a 12 ounce glass not even a pint. The female, hostess and server were really nice and a nice atmosphere, but I cannot believe what a rip off that place is never again.
I had an awesome experience here. I was greeted by a hostess immediately and seating right next to the door with a window view of Atlantic Avenue. I expected to be cold, but the heat was pumping right in my area which was an awesome (and I assume intentional) move to make sure every since seat was comfortable here. Me and my friend got an appetizer to split: the basket of fries. The fries were around $10 and they lasted us ALL NIGHT and were incredibly crunchy and tasty. I had two servings of The Long Island Gimlet which was a phenomenal drink — tasted like an elevated Moscow Mule. The service was attentive, friendly, and accommodating.
Great drinks, great food, great atmosphere, I'm just upset it took me so long to get over here! Phillip at the bar is a real gem, hilarious and a cocktail wizard. Can't wait to come back.
The best bar in Brooklyn and possibly the city, bar none. We returned night after night during our recent stay for delicious night caps, a warm and welcoming bartender and owner, and a retro space that feels like a dive bar with a simple food and cocktail menu that bely a truly elevated experience. Wish I could go back again but will have to plan my next visit instead!
We only got drinks here so I can't comment on the food. But the drinks were refreshing and staff were friendly. I loved the diner atmosphere. Would happily go back if I find myself in the neighborhood.
Fabulous place to enjoy a cocktail or six. Great people run the bar, and it's easy to wile away an afternoon.