Reviews
What Chard Nelson likes about Lantern's Keep:
This bar is truly exceptional, though quite small. This aspect makes it both its biggest advantage and its biggest drawback. Every drink we tried was fantastic, and the bartender was extremely knowledgeable, sharing plenty of useful tips and interesting stories. However, we did attempt to visit a couple of times on different occasions and found it closed. The hours can be somewhat inconsistent. Still, if you manage t... View all feedback. What anna cruz doesn't like about Lantern's Keep:
I ordered the Equator and the Fireman's Carry cocktails, but I wasn't impressed with either. They both seemed lacking in freshness and complexity and had a sour taste. Additionally, the bartender also served as the waiter, which seemed to put a lot of pressure on him. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
This bar is truly exceptional, though quite small. This aspect makes it both its biggest advantage and its biggest drawback. Every drink we tried was fantastic,...
read moreThe bar is small, which is typical for New York, but it didn't feel overcrowded. The service was excellent, and the drinks were top-notch!
The service was fantastic. There weren't any cocktails on the menu that intrigued me, so they crafted one based on my preferences, and it was delicious. Thank y...
read moreThis place makes great drinks! The bartenders really know their stuff.
AMAZING craft cocktails and bartenders. I would be here every evening if I lived in NYC. Can't wait to go back again.
This cocktail bar is a wonderful hidden gem! Be sure to try the "Wonder Lake." I wish we had stayed at the hotel as well — we'll definitely do that next time!
This is an under the radar gem of a speakeasy. Amazing cocktails. Great service. Super cool ambiance. One of my favorite places in New York City!
This is a charming little bar with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. The drinks are excellent!
Nice quiet bar. Reasonable price for cocktails given ambiance and service quality.
I ordered the Equator and the Fireman's Carry cocktails, but I wasn't impressed with either. They both seemed lacking in freshness and complexity and had a sour...
read moreWhat a cozy nostalgic speak easy. We stopped in before a show. It's in back of the hotel. The entrance is big unmarked blue doors. When you enter it feels as if...
read moreI really enjoyed the ambiance of this place. The staff was friendly and welcoming. It's a cozy little bar situated inside a small hotel with a charming speakeas...
read moreFor shame. This became a small institution of a bar that could truly make you a hell of one That has ceased. If you do the former keepers choice when asked of k...
read moreThe BEST bar in NYC. Go with dealer's choice and let these craft cocktail bartenders do their thing!
As others have explained post COVID Lantern 's Keep has no relationship or similarity to pre COVID Lantern 's Keep. Pre COVID, as recently as 2019, it still hel...
read more