Build Your Own Cookie - Feedback

#22 - Seafood - CHINCOTEAGUE ISLAND, American, Food

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.5 out of 5
Outstanding | 1868 reviews

Was Alexus Griffin at Build Your Own Cookie a mag?
BYOC is truly a dessert lover's dream! During our stay at Yogi Bear, which is just a quick three-minute drive away, we discovered this amazing spot. We spent only about $35 for our family of five, and it was well worth it. My kids had a blast customizing their sundaes, picking out their cookies, ice cream flavors, and toppings—it was wonderful to see their excitement! Personally, I found the ice cream to be the star... View all feedback.

Outside Images

Build Your Own Cookie Outside

Reviews from various websites

Google

Last update : 29.10.2023

4.7 ★ from 356 reviews
cara-jo
Cara 29.10.2023 - 18:50

Great place for a sweet treat! I got a chocolate chip cookie with sorbet and fresh strawberries. They have many options for cookies, ice cream, and toppings.

paul-simmons-doctor4
Paul 29.10.2023 - 18:50

Great cookie and ice cream selection, and the quality and taste were outstanding. Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

michael-martz
Michael 29.10.2023 - 18:50

Service: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Homemade Cookie, Build Your Own Cookie, Cookie

alexus-griffin
Alexus 29.10.2023 - 18:50

BYOC is truly a dessert lover's dream! During our stay at Yogi Bear, which is just a quick three-minute drive away, we discovered this amazing spot. We spent only about $35 for our family of five, and it was well worth it. My kids had a blast customizing their sundaes, picking out their cookies, ice cream flavors, and toppings—it was wonderful to see their excitement! Personally, I found the ice cream to be the star of the show, though the cookies were also tasty. If you're looking for a fun and interactive dessert experience, BYOC is the ideal place. It's a favorite among the kids and equally satisfying for parents, making it a great choice for everyone!

ray-mc
Ray 29.10.2023 - 18:50

At first glance, it may appear simple and easy to miss, but this restaurant truly shines. It has quickly become a favorite during our trips to the island. Food: 5, Service: 5, Atmosphere: 5.

Menu

Last update : 02.05.2023

4.8 ★ from 8 reviews
goldner-mandy
Mandy 02.05.2023 - 12:21

An adorable and delicious food truck that sells cookie and ice cream treats! They have so many different flavors of ice-cream and a lot of different cookies to choose from (all of which are warm and homemade! I chose the cake batter sugar cookie with birthday cake ice-cream and rainbow sprinkles, and my boyfriend chose the cookie sandwich with chocolate chip cookies, and cookies and cream ice-cream with peanut butter cups mixed in. Both were delicious! This is such a fun little food stop, and they have a lot of outdoor seating (all with umbrellas to shade from the sun and some of the tables are made from repurposed rain barrels, which I thought was really cool!!

lebsack-clyde
Clyde 02.05.2023 - 12:21

Definitely a place to stop by on your way to or from the beach, you pick a base- warm cookie, doughnut etc., Then your ice cream and toppings. While I do agree it's a bit of a wait because the person taking your order also makes the food, it's well worth it!

jurica07
Jurica 02.05.2023 - 12:21

Such a fun idea! Super yummy. It's as easy as 1-2-3. 1) Pick your WARM cookie. 2) Pick your favorite ice cream. 3) Pick your topping. Our whole family loved it so much we went back the next day.

jurica07
Jurica 02.05.2023 - 12:21

Went multiple times while visiting the area, delicious each time! Definitely one of the favorite parts of our trip

mikel-runolfsson
Mikel 02.05.2023 - 12:21

Many selections of flavors and toppings, but I thought that for a shop that is based around and named after their cookies, the cookies were not so good and some of the ice cream flavors did not taste very much of what they should.

Foursquare

Last update : 23.02.2025

2.5 ★ from 2 reviews
sarah-kurpel
Sarah 23.02.2025 - 17:22

Coffee and cookies cream! The chocolate chip cookies are fantastic.

tim-male
Tim 23.02.2025 - 17:22

The fudgy brownie paired with vanilla ice cream and drizzled with caramel was absolutely perfect!

Facebook
4.9 ★ from 39 reviews
Tripadvisor
4.9 ★ from 312 reviews
Yelp
4.4 ★ from 54 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.9 ★ from 346 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.9 ★ from 751 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near CHINCOTEAGUE ISLAND