Outermost Inn - Feedback

As for accommodations, the Inn is currently no longer accepting room reservations; only the restaurant is open at this time. The food and drinks are outstanding... read more As for accommodations, the Inn is currently no longer accepting room reservations; only the restaurant is open at this time. The food and drinks are outstanding!

The diners were quite loud and rude. The lobster dumpling had no discernible lobster, and the peach dessert also lacked much peach flavor. The scallops were pre... read more The diners were quite loud and rude. The lobster dumpling had no discernible lobster, and the peach dessert also lacked much peach flavor. The scallops were prepared decently. One table behind us was dropping the F-bomb repeatedly, and a young woman at a nearby table was shouting her part of the conversation, which we could hear from the parking lot. The location is beautiful, but the ill-mannered customers really detracted from the atmosphere.

The food was merely mediocre and significantly overpriced for what we received. We were never offered coffee with our desserts, which was disappointing. When th... read more The food was merely mediocre and significantly overpriced for what we received. We were never offered coffee with our desserts, which was disappointing. When they ran out of the filet, we were given the option of Wagyu instead. One member of our party decided to take that option, but we were hit with a $10 upcharge that wasn’t mentioned in advance on what was supposed to be a prix fixe menu. We ended up paying $120 per person, and honestly, the meal and dessert did not justify that cost. Their website advertised a price of $115, but then they added an extra percentage for a "kitchen appreciation fee." We left feeling shocked by the total we had to pay. Instead of remembering the meal, all we could think about was how overcharged we felt. On a positive note, the location was lovely. If you view the cost of the meal as a ticket to enjoy a beautiful setting, you might find a way to rationalize it.

Food, view, and vibe are all phenomenal Rooms: 5 Service: 5 Location: 5 read more Food, view, and vibe are all phenomenal Rooms: 5 Service: 5 Location: 5

I’m a chef and I absolutely love trying new places anywhere I go. My wife and I came here on our honeymoon in late October and they were open for lunch. We spen... read more I’m a chef and I absolutely love trying new places anywhere I go. My wife and I came here on our honeymoon in late October and they were open for lunch. We spent time in Manhattan eating and Michelin star places as well as Boston and all over Martha’s Vineyard. This was straight up the best meal I’ve ever had. We went Thursday October 22, whoever was cooking that day is cooking perfect food. I was blown away and that doesn’t happen often, my wife went to the bathroom and I was staring at the leftover sauces and liquids at the bottom of our plates literally licking them up. I was blown away!

This was the last stop of an eight day trip to the Cape for my mom and I. read more This was the last stop of an eight day trip to the Cape for my mom and I.

This understated, elegant, tasteful and perfectly cozy inn and restaurant are superlative for the ambiance, food and service. read more This understated, elegant, tasteful and perfectly cozy inn and restaurant are superlative for the ambiance, food and service.

For the most beautiful sunset eat dinner on the island Chef tasting menu is seasonal and had good local choices. read more For the most beautiful sunset eat dinner on the island Chef tasting menu is seasonal and had good local choices.

We had a great experience on the terrace. The food was delicious and the service was great. Would definitely go back! read more We had a great experience on the terrace. The food was delicious and the service was great. Would definitely go back!

The pasta, atmosphere, and service at this restaurant were all excellent. I have already suggested this place to numerous friends. We will definitely be returni... read more The pasta, atmosphere, and service at this restaurant were all excellent. I have already suggested this place to numerous friends. We will definitely be returning to sample the pizza!