Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Watermill:
This restaurant is amazing. All homemade dishes. The 1000s island dressing on the salad bar was the best I had. Fried bologne Sandwich-Yummy. The buffet also had a great looking food that is all homemade! Sandra, our waitress was so sweet. Great place to stop while traveling on 65 View all feedback.
What wolftracker75 doesn't like about Watermill:
Excellent eating experience! Good old comfort foods. The taste was great, not too much seasoning, but not bland either. All the employees we had contact with were super nice and friendly. And the price for an all you can eat buffet and salad bar with drink and dessert included is a real bargain. So glad we stopped here instead of some chain restaurant. Loved the homey atmosphere of the building as well. We will defin... View all feedback.
This place doesn’t look like much from the inside outside, but the fried catfish of the best I’ve had. Perfect amount of breading that crisps up nicely, while the fish itself stays tender and juicy. The salad bar has a nice selection, nothing fancy, but enough to make a tasty salad. The pot roast was also really good. Hubby doesn’t like catfish but even he went back for seconds.
The biscuits and gravy don't miss. Reminds me of grandma's gravy, it's so good. They treat you right and fill your belly for more than a fair price. I will be there every morning. Highly recommended! Stop in and try them out.
Pancakes were absolutely scrumptious. Service is excellent. Dinner was tasty. 1/5/23 Come here if you want a delectable double cheeseburger grilled to heavenly perfection. Curly fries were the best. Sharon waited on us and she and the staff deserve recognition. . 1/20/24 My family and I are still supporting this stellar restaurant. We enjoyed a good ol' country breakfast this morning. Order the pork chop and eggs from the menu with a short stack. You will leave a happy, full customer!
Very old place, probably very hoppin ' in the day, but really dated now. Stopped on our way from Florida to Indiana, largely because we saw buffet online. Well, it is true that they had a buffet, but the meats were catfish and breaded tenderloin. Neither seemed very high quality. The veggies and desserts were good but nothing exciting. Now, the cost was very reasonable $13, I think) so that should have been a clue. The gal who was acting as host, server, and cashier was really nice. She was the best part of the visit. This is one of those places that was really popular years ago that hasn 't really kept up. We 'll see what the future holds. Wish you luck.
Small restaurant/dinner with an old school atmosphere. The main attraction is the all you can eat self serve buffet, offering a salad bar, a hot meal bar and some desserts for $10. The cooked meals are fresh and good. The desserts are very yummy, I recommend both the peach cobbler and the banana pudding. The staff was very nice and welcoming.
Full Menu
Download Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
