Reviews
What User likes about Eileen's Colossal Cookies- Casper, Wy:
they are the best sugar cookies I have eaten. amazing frosting job every time I got it. I live hours away and get them for special occasions. they are jisr amazing! View all feedback. What Cherie doesn't like about Eileen's Colossal Cookies- Casper, Wy:
In store cookies are fine, never order the frozen fundraiser peanut butter cookie dough. It tastes stale/rotten both raw and baked, and completely crumbles into dust in your hands so its hard to portion out. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
They are the best sugar cookies I have eaten. amazing frosting job every time I got it. I live hours away and get them for special occasions. they are jisr amaz...
read moreBest cookies ever! talented decorators with amazing results! we love to order cookies for special occasions or just get a tasty bite! delicious!
These ladies are absolutely the best. called today and ordered a cookie for a worker. they have made there and a fabulous job even our company logo. thanks for...
read moreThey are the tattoo cookie artists! Delicious, soft and I am going back for more!
Today we ordered some cookies for an employee who was leaving for the military. We could not have been more impressed with the designs they did for us. We will...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreEileen's Cookies has garnered a loyal following for its delectable offerings and exceptional service. Customers rave about the freshness and softness of the in-store cookies, particularly the sugar cookies, which are praised for their exquisite frosting. The friendly staff, Nick and Heather, create a welcoming atmosphere, remembering regulars' preferences. For special occasions, their cookie cakes, including the impressive monster cookie cake, leave patrons in awe. While caution is advised regarding their frozen peanut butter cookie dough, the overall experience of warmth, cleanliness, and tasty treats makes Eileen's a beloved destination for cookie enthusiasts.
Me and my granddaughter have gone here many times and we love them I recommend them this places cookies are the best!
Ordered birthday cookies last min, and then needed them a day early due to last min surgery. They were wonderful, and very accommodating to my crazy life and sc...
read moreAbsolutely love this cookie place! Staff is always friendly helpful!! They are so fast with cookie orders!!! These are by far the best cookies in town! They mad...
read moreThe best! Heather is a gem and absolutely creative!!
My work was kind enough to get me this cookie cake. Best ever. Hate to say it but this is the best cookie I have tasted lol ngl. ??? just want to savor it. Will...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI absolutely adore the cookies at this place! Their customer service is fantastic as well!
Very friendly and helpful. The cookies are good. The texture of the larger cookies are more desirable than the smaller cookies in my opinion. They’ve done sever...
read moreAlways love the delicious cookies here. We got a cookie cake cookies to match for our 2 year old's birthday recently. I was so impressed with the art! Highly re...
read moreThe staff is incredibly friendly, and the cookies are not only delicious but also beautifully presented.
My husband and I LOVE Eileen's Cookies. Nick and Heather have awesome customer service. They are so nice and great people to get to know. Whenever we walk in th...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more