Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What K likes about Big Dom's Bagel Shop:
I'm from the North, have lived in New Haven, and have had countless bagels in the City. Dom's has a great bagel here. Grab an Egg, Bacon, Cheddar on an Everything with arugula, red onion, and their Sassy Sauce and tell me I'm lying. For the people giving four stars because they sell out, well folks, that's pretty much the gold standard for a great spot and a message that you're going to have to order earlier next tim... View all feedback.
What Eric Alexander doesn't like about Big Dom's Bagel Shop:
I had a really delicious bagel there about a year ago. Love the location and usually the staff is friendly they may have just been worn out and tired by the time I got there)but the past three times I've been, 9:30, 10, and 10:30 on different days have either been closed because they sold out, or had 2 poppyseed bagels left. So unfortunately I'm taking them off my list of suggestions. Maybe the business model is to n... View all feedback.
Even a simple egg and cheese on sesame was so delicious. And the bagel donuts are yummy. Also a very cute and well utilized interior space
They make great bagels, but ordering is a hassle. If you don’t put an order in before they open good luck!Edit: They’ve switched to in person only ordering during business hours on weekends. You can still order online before they open, which is what I recommend.
List a public phone number and answer your phone. Online ordering often goes down with no explanation. Ordering in person is usually 15+ minute wait. The food is good but wow what a consistently awful ordering experience. And I'm paying $10 for a sandwich and your only seating is exterior??? LIST A PHONE NUMBER AND TAKE ORDERS OVER THE PHONE wow it's not rocket science
I thoroughly enjoyed the BLT bagel (salt pepper bagel) I had for breakfast over the weekend. My sister had a bacon and cheese on an everything bagel, and my partner had a bacon, egg, and cheese on an asiago bagel their only complaint was that there was TOO much egg! Tasty! Will be back again!
Very friendly, online ordered 2dozen bagel for a wedding brides mate/friends morning breakfast, sliced! The berry spread was excellent. added a lox and cheese bagel to go for the driver ?Stop in and decided to get a “box” of coffee. they quickly brewed up a fresh pot. great service! Bagels tasted great. Our guest loved them even after a day or two later!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
