Graeter's Ice Cream Carmel

Having lived in Cincinnati for nearly 12 years, I am quite familiar with Graeter's ice cream shop. However, I must say that the waffle cone portions at this particular location can be lacking. In my opinion, the scoops look more like they belong in a sugar cone rather than a waffle cone. Typically, at other places I've visited, the ice cream scoop matches the shape of the waffle cone.

Perfect work day treat- Quick service, not busy on a Wednesday at 4pm, key lime pie ice cream was amazing! I would definitely recommend trying it before it?s discontinued. The young ladies staffing the front were professional, nice and attentive. Place was chill and clean. I enjoyed this experience a lot more than my first experience with Graters in Broad Ripple.

Graeter's is definitely one of the best ice cream options in Carmel. They have many different flavor options and it never fails to satisfy. If you go between September 8th and September 18th (2022), there is a fundraiser for The Cure Starts Now which supports kids with a brain cancer called DIPG.

I visited Graeter's after nearly a year and ordered the popular black raspberry chocolate chip ice cream scoop and an 1870 Tower Sundae. I always enjoy the chunks of chocolate chips in the black raspberry ice cream. The sundae was a decadent chocolate Bundt cake with hot fudge and topped with pecans. It was absolutely amazing and delicious! There weren't too many customers on a Sunday evening, so there were plenty of empty seats to sit and enjoy our desserts. The staff was also following all masking and safety precautions.

This restaurant is gorgeous and the staff is friendly and accommodating! There are so many options to choose from that it might be difficult to decide. However, you can't make a wrong choice. If you've never tried Graeter's ice cream before, definitely treat yourself to it! You won't be disappointed!