Pelly's Fish Market Cafe - Carlsbad

#16 - Seafood - Carlsbad, Fresh Seafood Salad, Seafood Markets

Pelly's Fish Market Cafe

★ 4.2 / 5 (4026 reviews)

Pelly's restaurant offers a diverse seafood menu that leaves diners with mixed reviews. While some rave about the freshness of their fish tacos and delightful outdoor atmosphere, others express disappointment with service and dish quality. Guests have enjoyed standout options like cioppino and fish and chips, but the New England clam chowder received criticism for its odd texture and lack of flavor. Additionally, patrons noted that the high prices do not always align with the food experience. Despite some positive encounters, the inconsistency in meal preparation and overall service has led to a lack of enthusiasm for repeat visits.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Patricia

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 4026 reviews

Was Anonym at Pelly's Fish Market Cafe a mag?
they were here twice in our socal holiday. for the first time for fabulous seafood tacos and fresh fish from the market. 2 nights worth fresh fish and both were fantastic. ends our hikes in torrey pines and decided to refresh here for more couples meal times. the yellow **** was simply added to the case and was so fresh. tomorrow is the sea bass, cannot wait! great place for dunes and fresh catch. super friendly serv... View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about Pelly's Fish Market Cafe:
Used to be a loyal customer. Staff is repeatedly not adhering to current California mask mandate. I will not return until management enforces the mask mandate for their staff. Sorry Sam’s widow, you need to get tough on your staff. You ask your customers to do it, you need to ask your staff to do it too. View all feedback.

Matty

09.02.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

I enjoyed the halibut sandwich and crab cakes very much. The sandwich was hearty and the fish was so fresh. The tartar sauce is excellent. They should bottle it! The crab cakes were delicious with a generous amount of crab and just the right amount of seasoning.

Mike

09.02.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Simply put, Pelly’s has no peer when it comes to fresh fish retail and their Cafe has the best seafood prices anywhere and their fish while served on paper plates is the best value in the whole San Diego area. Seeing is believing. Everything is made from scratch and all homemade.