Reviews
What Brandon Hall doesn't like about Pompeii Steakhouse:
Wasn't happy, got myself all worked up for a steak, walked miles from the hotel and it was closed for a holiday. Apparently it's pretty good and worth a try and it I'm in Carlisle again I'll give it another chance. Had to settle for an average pizza in the town square. Bottom....... View all feedback. What User likes about Pompeii Steakhouse:
was a bit worried when the steak came out and out how it was well cooked, but that was short lived when we realized that it was on a big hot stone where the meat was ready to cook. it meant we could cut a bit and every piece of steak was hot and spot on. the staff was friendly and helpful and easy to chat. the place is small, cozy and had a nice atmosphere, the people have been happy chatting. it is not a cheaper pla... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Amazing food and service at this restaurant. We ordered the shakers and they were packed with so much meat that we were too full for dessert!
I was a little concerned when my steak arrived and it looked well cooked, but my worries quickly disappeared when I realized it was on a large hot stone, ready...
read moreIncredible steak! The unique way they serve a blue rare steak, raw with a sizzling hot plate of salted granite, is impressive. The owner is very knowledgeable a...
read moreOur favorite restaurant in Carlisle. The staff is nice, helpful and friendly. The food is always fantastic. If you like steak, this is the place to go, although...
read moreWithout a doubt the steak is good. My only bug with the place is, it isn't cheap and you cook the steak yourself. So although the concept is good, you could rep...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNestled in the heart of Carlisle, this cozy restaurant tantalizes meat lovers with its exceptional steaks, served on sizzling hot stones that allow diners to customize their cooking. The welcoming atmosphere fosters friendly conversations, enhanced by attentive staff eager to share their knowledge of the menu. While the prices may be on the higher side, patrons agree that the quality of the locally sourced meat justifies the cost. Alongside delectable steak options, a variety of fish and vegetarian dishes cater to diverse palates. This hidden gem certainly deserves a visit for an unforgettable dining experience.