Crosby's - Caledonia

#23 - Pizza - Caledonia, Italian, Delivery Services

Crosby's

Crosby's
3.3 / 5 (52 reviews)

Description

Crosby's Caledonia, located in the charming town of Caledonia, NY, is a beloved Italian restaurant with a diverse menu sure to please every palate. Open daily from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM, it's the perfect spot for a cozy dinner for two or a festive gathering with friends and family. Reservations are recommended—call (585) 538-2300 to secure your table. If you’re looking to explore similar culinary experiences, don’t miss out on Village Inn and Reminisce Soda Fountain. We’d love to hear about your experience, so feel free to leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Robert

Feedback

★ 3.3 / 5 from 52 reviews
donna-shelton-1
29.10.2023

I was just in Crosby's and I so wanted a slice of pizza. I was standing in line and I watch an employee moving food around in the pizza warmer. She was not wear gloves and touching the food with her hands!!!!!!!!!! I told her I wanted a slice of pizza till I watched her touching the food with her hands. She told me to my face I was wrong I can not believe it. I told her she can not say she did not do it when O watched her. That place is very crappy. I so wish we got 7-11 store.

ladaobi
25.02.2023

I was just in Crosby's and I wanted a piece of pizza. I was standing in the snake and I see an employee moving the food in the pizza warmer. She wore no gloves and touched the food with her hands!!!!!!!!!! I told her I wanted a piece of pizza until I saw her touch the food with her hands. She told me to my face that I was wrong, I can't believe it. I told her she can't say she didn't do it when O observed her. This place is very fucking. I wish we had a deal of 7 months.

cyiaw
25.02.2023

I recently visited Crosby's and wanted to grab a slice of pizza. While I was waiting in line, I saw an employee handling the food in the pizza warmer without any gloves, touching the food with her bare hands! I had already asked for a piece of pizza, but once I noticed her touching the food, I changed my mind. When I pointed it out to her, she insisted that I was mistaken, which I found unbelievable. I told her that I had seen her do it, and she still denied it. I was really put off by the experience. This place has some serious issues. I wish there were a better alternative nearby.

robert-grant-mechani
01.10.2024

The customer service at this restaurant is very poor. The gas pump was locked and wouldn't release my card, and it took a full 10 minutes for the pump to fill my car. I also noticed two other customers leave due to experiencing the same problem.

lala-r-1
29.10.2023

This gas station serves the best pizza I've ever had! We tried the chicken wing pizza this time, and it was fantastic. They also offer delicious breakfast pizzas and sandwiches.

FAQ

The rooms in the restaurant are wheelchair accessible and can also be used with a wheelchair or physiological limitations.

The restaurant accepts various credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.