Casey's - Caledonia

#28 - Pizza - Caledonia, Breakfast, Lunch
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.9 / 5 (218 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of Casey's from Caledonia featuring all 5 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Casey's in Caledonia, WI, is a popular American restaurant known for its inviting atmosphere and impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Diners rave about their experiences, making it a must-visit destination. Today, Casey's welcomes guests from 5:00 AM to 10:00 PM. For inquiries about peak times or to reserve your table, feel free to call (262) 639-2225. With a diverse menu that caters to every palate, including delicious vegetarian options, there’s truly something for everyone at Casey's. If you're looking for similar dining experiences, be sure to check out Hushers Pub Grill and McDonald's. Enjoyed your meal? We’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: monteazul

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Inside Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food Casey's Food

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 218 reviews

Was John Laich at Casey's a mag?
The gas pumps are excellent, the store is well-stocked, and the restrooms are clean. However, all the squeegees for cleaning car windows are either streaky or broken. View all feedback.

What Lee Musurlian dislikes about Casey's:
WARNING TO FEMALE CUSTOMERS! My wife had a troubling experience with a clerk named Kelly, who threatened her twice in the store regarding the use of her rewards number. It's hard to believe, right? The general manager was very friendly on the phone and mentioned that Kelly would be fired, but I'm not sure if that actually happened. Husbands and boyfriends, please consider accompanying your wives or girlfriends if Kel... View all feedback.

charrie-ferguson-res-1
08.05.2025

I must admit, I 've never been to or heard of a Casey 's until today. The experience was Great to say the least. Their pizza is ABSOLUTELY AMAZING. Definitely added to my top 5 list. The staff was very pleasent and welcoming. The store was literallyshinning clean in every area. Shelves were stocked and I literally didn 't see one thing to complain about. This place is now onmy must stop list anytime I see the name ?????

thomas-nelson-fox335
08.05.2025

Its too industrial looking to be a general store . And the pizza is expensive for the quality. original post rated 3 stars. As a man I think it 's important to make your wrongs right and admit when you were wrong. Although the decor may notscream general store, and the pizza is a bit pricey but everything is now a days. I think my original review was harsh. Thestaff is always friendly and genuine, I always look forward to stopping in. The rewards program really make filling up my trucka lot less painful. I have come to absolutely love their breakfast pizza, and breakfast in general. So back to what really soldme on this place. It 's the staff! Always met with a smile and conversations that have evolved beyond small talk. The customerservice is top notch for sure. One time I bought a prewrapped cold burrito and to my disappointment it was moldy on the inside.The date on the package was still good and I was a bit unhappy. This is one of the items they don 't make themselves they justsell them. I was met with wonderful customer service. They offered to fully refund me, replace the item, and offered me acomplimentary donut and drink of my choice. Now that was too much to offer, in my opinion. So I just ended up taking a grillitem and a bottle of water happily. I really have grown to love Casey 's there 's no better gas station to go to on any given dayto and from work. I highly recommend the breakfast pizza it 's one of my favs on a Saturday morning, breakfast, lunch and dinnerlol. Ps the prices aren 't that bad if you buy a full pizza ????.

glen-westphal-3
08.05.2025

Casey's offers fantastic prices on gas in my area, especially for E85, which is the only fuel I use. They typically have the lowest price around, but I was disappointed when the price jumped from $2.42 to $2.90 a gallon. Despite this setback, I still love their menu!

monteazul-seymour-2
08.05.2025

The staff at Casey's is outstanding! We visit frequently, and they are always helpful, friendly, and have a wonderful sense of humor. It's our go-to place!

sharon-kreuzpaintner-2
08.05.2025

During my visit, I only purchased gas, but I noticed they offer some really delicious hot food. They also have a wide variety of drink options and an abundance of snacks.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.