Casey's - Buffalo Center

Breakfast, Lunch, Pizza

Casey's

Casey's
4.1 / 5 (150 reviews)

Description

Once-beloved local convenience-store pizzeria serves hot, tasty pizzas and breadsticks with occasionally generous extras and genuinely friendly staff. Yet reliability is a recurring problem: automated ordering and posted hours have failed patrons, phones often go unanswered, and chronic understaffing or single-employee shifts cause long waits, missed orders and operational frustration. Menu shortages and uneven management undercut otherwise good food — regulars enjoy the product but urge improvements to staffing, hours and order systems.

Last update: 29.05.2026 from: Willilam

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 150 reviews
mreinger-flower4
18.05.2023

I frequently order food online, and they often call to let me know my order will be ready sooner than expected. Occasionally, they pick up my orders for me. The staff here are genuinely great people.

quentin71
18.05.2023

A great spot to stop by—offering delicious food and snacks!

dietrich-leonard
18.05.2023

Keep up the great work, and you might just achieve fame!

willilam-stevens
08.06.2024

I placed an order through the automated system and was told it would be ready at 5:27. When I arrived, there were people waiting in line for 15 minutes. I had to finally push my way to the counter where the woman working didn't even know I had ordered. She informed me that she was the only one working and had other orders to fill, including mine which hadn't even been started. It made me wonder how the automated system could accurately predict when the pizza would be ready if it didn't consider the backup in the kitchen. I'm not blaming the pizza maker, but at least when speaking to a real person they could provide an estimated time.

brad-thill-1
08.06.2024

Worst Casey's store in Iowa. Poor service, attitudes from employees. Dozens of people in line waiting.

FAQ

You can also pay for your dishes with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.