Sofia's - Reviews

Italian, Cheese, Pasta

Reviews summary

Overall Total Score
4.5 out of 5
Outstanding | 121 reviews

Was Anonym at Sofia's a mag?
We moved to Florida last year but we were back in NY for the Christmas holiday and we had to come to Sofia's for dinner even though it to took us almost hours to get there with the NY traffic, need I say more. Outstanding food, great staff! Paul, Franco and rest of the staff made us feel like we never left. View all feedback.

Reviews from various users

Menu

Last update : 16.11.2022

4.6 ★ from 30 reviews

Authentic, delicious food presented by a attentive staff in a beautiful way. I'm back and recommend it very much.

Franco was excellent made our dinning experience super. his professionalism and his knowledge is excellent. many thanks, franco

Very nice service was excellent. eating was very good. I'm here several times.

Not sure what all the five star reviews are about. The restaurant is pretty, our waiter was not particularly friendly and the food was average. We went on a Sunday night and they were out of snapper and swordfish. There were only 3 tables being served. I had the Sofia’s special salad which was VERY unspecial! It consisted of lettuce, tomato and a couple of cubes of beets. I’ve had better salads from a corner deli. Since they were out of swordfish, I had tuna. It was not a quality piece. I asked for it very rare, but since it was a thin slice, that was impossible to do. My friend had the branzino special which looked nice. The salmon was swimming in a balsamic sauce. My husband was happy with his tortolini but wished they had a better quality cheese to be grated over it. All they had was cheese in a shaker. Not the sign of a quality restaurant. Average food- definitely not 5 star!!

We moved to Florida last year but we were back in NY for the Christmas holiday and we had to come to Sofia's for dinner even though it to took us almost 2 hours to get there with the NY traffic, need I say more. Outstanding food, great staff! Paul, Franco and rest of the staff made us feel like we never left.

Sofia's Restaurant offers a mixed dining experience. While some diners found the food to be average and the service lacking, others praised the outstanding food and staff, with special mention of waiter Franco. The restaurant is considered a neighborhood gem, providing a relaxing and delicious meal. Despite occasional issues like overcooked meat, many continue to appreciate the genuine and mouthwatering dishes served by a welcoming team. Overall, Sofia's proves to be a favorite dining spot for those seeking a comforting and flavorful meal experience.

Opentable

Last update : 30.09.2024

4.4 ★ from 91 reviews
garyk
30.09.2024

Genuine and mouthwatering dishes served with care by a friendly staff in a lovely presentation. I will definitely return and I highly recommend this restaurant.

Good Rated Restaurants near Brooklyn