Polonica - Reviews

I love this place, food was excellent I am very sad to see them go : I'm hoping they can find another spot to reopen! read more I love this place, food was excellent I am very sad to see them go : I'm hoping they can find another spot to reopen!

I am so terribly upset. Live in Bay Ridge my whole life. Have passed this restaurant 1,000's of times and heard millions of great things about the place. I fina... read more I am so terribly upset. Live in Bay Ridge my whole life. Have passed this restaurant 1,000's of times and heard millions of great things about the place. I finally got here for the first time a just a few weeks ago and is was so good. Last night had the goulash Placek po wegiersku. Hungarian pancakes. Too large potato pancakes with a combination of beef goulash, tomatoes, and hot peppers in the center. OMG, my eyes rolled back in my head like a shark's.. the flavor was amazing rich and spicy. And the beef was tender. Sandwiched between two of the most crispy potato pancakes I have ever had. The owner said that they are planning on coming back I hope sooner than later!! I just discovered this hidden gem and now it's going away. Good luck to them and hope to see them back in the neighborhood very soon!!!!!

So happy to have this wonderful restaurant back! The place looks amazing and the food is as great as always! read more So happy to have this wonderful restaurant back! The place looks amazing and the food is as great as always!

The food is PERFECT every time we come, we drive from Staten Island for some home style Polish food. My favorite is the Hungarian pancakes, beef stew between tw... read more The food is PERFECT every time we come, we drive from Staten Island for some home style Polish food. My favorite is the Hungarian pancakes, beef stew between two potato pancakes, and the variety of salads before your food comes it also my favorite, DELICIOUS

Polonica has returned and is better than ever! Today's lunch was amazing, just like it has been for over 20 years. It's truly the best. Welcome back! read more Polonica has returned and is better than ever! Today's lunch was amazing, just like it has been for over 20 years. It's truly the best. Welcome back!

I’m giving an extra star for the host's politeness, but the pierogi mix I ordered to go only contained potato and some unfamiliar substance. They had no flavor... read more I’m giving an extra star for the host's politeness, but the pierogi mix I ordered to go only contained potato and some unfamiliar substance. They had no flavor at all.

This charming little restaurant offers a distinctive experience with incredible food. The service is impressively quick. The barley soup was hearty and satisfyi... read more This charming little restaurant offers a distinctive experience with incredible food. The service is impressively quick. The barley soup was hearty and satisfying, while the fried pierogis provided a delightful, crispy crunch in every bite.

One of my favorite restaurants in Bay Ridge. The comfort food here is exceptional. Whether you dine in or order takeout, the service is always excellent. My... read more One of my favorite restaurants in Bay Ridge. The comfort food here is exceptional. Whether you dine in or order takeout, the service is always excellent. My...