Reviews
What Greg K likes about Nagle's Bagels:
Honestly, the quality has slipped a lot in the past year or so. This is the second order in a row where the order was just wrong (sausage sandwiches instead of bacon). And the regular bagels with cream cheese are just dry and crumbly...maybe they were day old bagels? Honestly, I love the place and the vibe and location but two straight orders where the quality was really low, and the items were incorrect. I think I a... View all feedback. What Joseph Giambona doesn't like about Nagle's Bagels:
Refused to let me order with my service dog because he didn’t have a service animal vest on, which is NOT required by law. They apparently don’t know disability rights and did not care. Will be finding another neighborhood place to take my business. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
The flavor was good, but the eggs were overcooked and my bagel was flattened. The everything bagel did not have much seasoning and it was only on one side.
The best place in Brooklyn for Bagel!!! You have a lot of options! The staff is very kind! I went there 5 times during my stay in Brooklyn. The only negative is...
read moreHonestly I thought the ppl working were so nice and silly—gave great recs and advice—and the sandwiches were incredible. I got the gotham and it was mind-blowin...
read moreI stayed in Brooklyn a few blocks away from Nagels, and every time I visit the city, I make sure to stop by this place. Nagels has the best and most delicious b...
read moreThe bagel was good made with solid ingredients, but nothing original.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNagel’s Bagel Shop, a quaint establishment in Brooklyn, offers a range of bagels that spark varied culinary reactions. While patrons enjoy the freshness and unique creations like whole wheat everything bagels with horseradish cream cheese, others raise concerns over consistency and service efficiency. Some customers appreciate the warm, friendly ambiance, citing the charming decor and relaxed sidewalk seating, while a few have faced issues with order accuracy and unapproved service dog policies. Despite the occasional chaos during peak hours, loyal fans persist, returning for the delicious offerings and inviting atmosphere that has made Nagel's a neighborhood staple.
Refused to let me order with my service dog because he didn’t have a service animal vest on, which is NOT required by law. They apparently don’t know disability...
read moreCan't beat a fresh bagel with whatever you want on it. Great service and awesome vibes. Just go in and say hello!!
Really yummy bagels and reasonable prices. Got a veggie sandwich with a poppyseed bagel and a cold brew for $12 not bad. Fresh and yummy. Cute shop too
Decent bagel bit somewhat haphazard ordering and serving system. Rating should be seen with a grain of salt as I only had a buttered everything bagel. This plac...
read moreThe bagels are fine. Kind of small. Not much outer crust. A little dry, and toasting makes them v dry. Better than a deli for sure tho.The operations on a busy...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThis bagel shop is good, they have the expected bagels and they have some more interesting ones to try too. Their service was very warm and friendly and the sho...
read moreHonestly, the quality has slipped a lot in the past year or so. This is the second order in a row where the order was just wrong (sausage sandwiches instead of...
read morePerfectly soft crispy bagel with cream cheese just this side of tangy. Also immaculate vibes: relaxed sidewalk seating, not too crowded but obviously popular, t...
read moreBagel was not special and honestly felt insulted by the tiny cup of $4 bacon pieces that I got on the side.
Best bagel shop in America. Receipts! best bagels and salmon anywhere, charming super fast service. community vibe every time. delicious and adorable!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more