Gnarly Eats - Reviews
Reviews summary
Was Alex P at Gnarly Eats a mag?
The Buttermilk Fried Chicken Burger was the best chicken sandwich I've ever had, BAR NONE. Seriously, the first bite was orgasmic. I threw in some chick fil-a sauce and I was literally in heaven. View all feedback.
What Elise CMuss dislikes about Gnarly Eats:
I ordered some food and the adult grilled cheese was quite disappointing, primarily because there was hardly any cheese in it. The Butternut Squash and Kale soup was also too salty. Overall, I would rate the food a 1 out of 5. View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 08.08.2023
Food so good I forgot to take a picture! We got the chicken sandwich and beef brisket and WOW are they delicious!! It's a cute little shop with a few tables inside and one table outside and the service was super quick! The homemade strawberry basil lemonade is quite literally perfect- not to sweet! Would def come back!
It always the small places that bring the big taste. I really enjoyed the buttermilk chicken burger and strawberry basil lemonade. The fries were a bit soggy but the onion rings were great! I’d highly suggest eating in as I can not image how well the food would travel and it seems best fresh out the kitchen. It’s a storefront spot so there’s only room for less than 10 people to dine. What else makes this place great, the service. Definitely a place to add to the frequent list.Kid-friendliness: Cheeseburger and fries never disappoints
It always the small places that bring the big taste. I really enjoyed the buttermilk chicken burger and strawberry basil lemonade. The fries were a bit soggy but the onion rings were great! I’d highly suggest eating in as I can not image how well the food would travel and it seems best fresh out the kitchen. It’s a storefront spot so there’s only room for less than 10 people to dine. What else makes this place great, the service. Definitely a place to add to the frequent list.Kid-friendliness: Cheeseburger and fries never disappoints
Stumbled in here absolutely starving after the movies. It is so tiny (but not in a bad way, in a really comfortable way prob not the best for first dates lol). The service was so so fast and friendly. Not sure of his name, but will ask next time. Will def go back again and again and again. Thai tea and loaded fries were to dieeee
However, my only small complaint is that the space is quite cramped, and there's no music playing, which makes it difficult to relax and enjoy time with friends. The atmosphere feels rather lifeless. It's a bit of a hidden gem that, to be honest, isn't very aesthetically pleasing. You could easily avoid this by ordering takeout or online, but it's a shame that such a fantastic food experience is paired with a less-than-inviting environment.
Nestled in a cozy corner, this restaurant offers a mixed yet memorable dining experience. Ranging from perfectly crafted burgers to tantalizing chicken sandwiches, the food shines with quality and flavor. While some dishes, like the adult grilled cheese, may disappoint and the fries could use improvement, standout items like the Buttermilk Fried Chicken Burger and savory shakes leave patrons ecstatic. The ambiance is charmingly intimate, though potentially cramped for larger groups. Quick service and a warm atmosphere invite repeat visits, making it a beloved spot among locals who appreciate both quality cuisine and attentive staff.
Last update : 04.08.2023
I remember when they first opened their doors, and the Beatles fried chicken sandwich was my absolute favorite. I'm pleased to say that, years later, it still holds that title. As a lifelong Brooklyn resident, I haven't tried every fried chicken sandwich in the city, but I've sampled plenty, and this one is definitely my favorite. The meat is tender and juicy, and the sandwich itself is huge and a fantastic deal! I'm so glad that time hasn't led them to compromise on quality or portion size. Additionally, the staff is always friendly and welcoming whenever I visit. I truly love this place!
DELICIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! A MUST-TRY!! The service was phenomenal and the food was even BETTER! We usually get takeout, but today we decided to dine in, and it was surprisingly even better! We thought it was amazing when we had it delivered as well! Thank you so much, Gnarly Eats!!
This is a fantastic place for bar food. The tater tots and corn dogs were absolutely satisfying!
My family and I ate here a couple days ago.. the food is very good and tasty. Definitely recommend this place. This is my to go spot and will 100% come here again. The food is just magnificent!
Last update : 10.03.2024
One of the most tender burgers I've ever had, perfectly crafted! No matter what your music preferences are, the Coldplay tracks really elevate the experience—they rock way harder than any Britrock I've heard!
The food was quite good, especially the chicken sandwich, which was delicious. However, the fries were a bit disappointing. The cheeseburger was decent too. The space is also somewhat cramped.
Absolutely five stars all around! A perfect 10! They serve the BEST burgers, and the shakes are incredible! The service was impeccable. The food met all my expectations. I highly recommend it!
Last update : 07.03.2023
I ordered delivery and it arrived incredibly quickly! I've visited this restaurant multiple times over the years, and my first experience was fantastic. Last year, however, it was just average.
Following my Thanksgiving dinner, I was craving a burger. Since I'm not from Brooklyn, my friend helped me find this spot, which had great reviews. The...
Last update : 28.10.2025
Astoundingly good food! It’s kid-friendly fare- burgers, fries, brisket- but all freshly-made and delicious. Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4 Service: Dine in Price per person: $10–20
Good Rated Restaurants near Brooklyn
★ 4.1 / 5 (1968 reviews)Delis Kosher Burgers Delivery ServicesMill Basin Kosher Delicatessen
Ave T 5823, 11234-4113 Brooklyn, US
★ 4.3 / 5 (950 reviews)Japanese Salad Breakfast-brunch RamenWasan Brooklyn
5th Avenue 55, 11217-2466 Brooklyn, US
★ 4.4 / 5 (4495 reviews)#20 Seafood in Brooklyn ItalianVerde on Smith
216 Smith St. New York, NY 11201, 11201-6533, Brooklyn, United States