Cafe 58 - Brooklyn

Pizza, American, International

Cafe 58

Cafe 58
4.1 / 5 (455 reviews)

Description

Nestled near the Brooklyn Army Terminal, Cafe 58 stands out as a surprising oasis amidst the industrial landscape of Sunset Park. This cozy diner and pizzeria prides itself on fresh, from-scratch cooking and generous portions. Diners rave about the exceptional pizza, particularly the flavorful sauce, often ranking it among the best even compared to offerings in Italian neighborhoods of NYC. A friendly family-owned establishment, Cafe 58 also serves delicious lunch specials, including options like pulled pork. With a welcoming atmosphere and dedicated owner, the cafe is a must-visit for anyone in the area, especially pizza lovers.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Patrick

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 455 reviews
sferry-ivy742
13.06.2022

The pizza here is really good. the best in the neighbourhood safe. Too bad they don't deliver late or late at night.

florence-mclaughlin
13.06.2022

I love this place. it is a cozy and quiet oasis on a giant block of sunset park near the brooklyn army terminals. the chefs prepare all food fresh from scratch every day, and the portions are very generous. if they like meat pizza, this is the place! but the best thing about cafe 58 is nod – the hard-working owner of the shop. he's a real shady.

margarita11
13.06.2022

I honestly didn't have high expectations, it's the only thing close to the ferry, and surrounded by warehouses.The pizza is amazing, the sauce in particular. I live in an Italian neighborhood in NYC, I eat a lot of good pizza, and this place stands up. I'm going back here every time I'm at that ferry stop.

patrick-debono-vine8
21.06.2024

Delicious pizza and efficient service. The restaurant is very clean, and they also offer outdoor seating. There are plenty of tasty slice options available, ready in no time. Although there is no table service, which is why I rated it 4 stars, I would certainly return if I'm in the area again.

anthony-lupo-1
21.06.2024

This restaurant not only offers outstanding food, but the service is exceptional as well. The owner personally greets each guest as if they've been friends for years. He is truly a gentleman and a scholar. I'm grateful to have such a fantastic spot near my workplace where I can enjoy a meal.

Menu

FAQ

The second closest stop is MTA-53rd St, located 621 meters away.

The joint offers the opportunity to view sports events on a TV / screen.

You can also pay for your meals with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.