Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.2 out of 5
Impressive | 2375 reviews

What Elena Rogers doesn't like about Antica Pesa:
That was very disappointing. One of the most disappointing meals. I expected so much more based on the price and ambiance. I honestly believe I would have gotten a tastier meal in a pizzeria, I have been in Italy and this is by no means a close equal to a good Rome restaurant. View all feedback. What John DeMauro likes about Antica Pesa:
This restaurant is a hidden Italian gem. I had ordered the amatriciana pasta and tiramisu. Their wine list has probably the best selection I've seen in NYC period. Staff are on point, knowledgeable, and attentive. This is my 3rd time here and just now writing a review because I wanted to make sure it wasn't a fluke with my first couple experiences. I will continue to come here. If you want to impress a date, this is... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Google
4.1 ★ from 661 reviews
Joseph
20.02.2024 - 17:16

As reviewed by others, the pasta dishes are superb along with the dessert. Their encrusted fish specialty wasn't on the pre fix menu, so I missed that.

Callum
20.02.2024 - 17:16

There is not, and never will there be, a more charming or talented bartender than Masssimiliano. Try the espresso martini (basic we know) with the Crema Di Caff...

read more
Patrick
20.02.2024 - 17:16

Great spot for date night with an intimate atmosphere, great wine list and cocktail menu, quick service. We shared cacio e pepe and the T-bone steak

Nick
20.02.2024 - 17:16

Absolutely loved this place and it had amazing Italian food that is comparable to the Italian restaurants with a month long wait. The service was impeccable and...

read more
Zach
20.02.2024 - 17:16

Had a fantastic time on a quiet Sunday night. Food was impeccable and the bartender (S/O Cesar! ensured I was properly taken care of. I’ll be back for sure!

Restaurantji
4.2 ★ from 398 reviews
Marcus
20.11.2023 - 20:56

The food is amazing! Best ingredients, home made icecream and Tiramisu. Excelent coxktails. The owner came and talked to us, the staff were incredibly nice and...

read more
Elena
20.11.2023 - 20:56

That was very disappointing. One of the most disappointing meals. I expected so much more based on the price and ambiance. I honestly believe I would have gotte...

read more
Karim
20.11.2023 - 20:56

The agent who welcomed us was very snobby. It was 9/15 8:30 reservation. She did not welcome us with good communication and she said we don't have reservation....

read more
Silvio
20.11.2023 - 20:56

Fantastic restaurant ! We did travel along the west coast (Portland, San Francisco, Los Angeles) and tried more than one Italian restaurants but Antica Pesa has...

read more
Ronit
20.11.2023 - 20:56

This restaurant is a must! Every single thing that we ate was deliciously prepared.We were a party of five and all agreed, the portions and flavors were all per...

read more
Int Restaurants
4.2 ★ from 1611 reviews
John
20.07.2023 - 16:29

This restaurant is a hidden Italian gem. I had ordered the amatriciana pasta and tiramisu. Their wine list has probably the best selection I've seen in NYC peri...

read more
Sabrina
20.07.2023 - 16:29

I had been looking forward to dining here after following them on Instagram for months. I try to save my carbs for special occasions so my boyfriend took me her...

read more
Nikhil
20.07.2023 - 16:29

OMG! Oh.my.god! This place is a gem! We had reservations at another place but due to a snafu, we were asked to wait for for an 1 hour. Looking around, open tabl...

read more
Sara
20.07.2023 - 16:29

If you are looking for an authentic Italian restaurant in New York, this is it. The place looks beautiful, great design, it reminds me of their location in Rome...

read more
Christopher
20.07.2023 - 16:29

Beautiful space, very accommodating staff (we were 30mins late but they found us a table after a bit of back and forth, very gracious of them) and a very classi...

read more
Sirved
5.0 ★ from 2 reviews
John
20.12.2023 - 04:15

I had been looking forward to dining here after following them on Instagram for months. I try to save my carbs for special occasions so my boyfriend took me her...

read more
John
20.12.2023 - 04:15

If you are looking for an authentic Italian restaurant in New York, this is it. The place looks beautiful, great design, it reminds me of their location in Rome...

read more
Doordash
4.4 ★ from 198 reviews
Hannah
01.03.2024 - 04:57

The Pollo e Camomilla is amazing from here! A massive size (easily feeds two) and comes with a delicious sauce and a nice side salad! I get it every time. Tiram...

read more
Gastroranking-us
3.7 ★ from 168 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Brooklyn

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 20 Skillman Ave., Brooklyn 11211, 11211-2225, United States
"Great food and atmosphere! Would definitely go back"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 336 Myrtle Ave, 11205, Brooklyn, US, United States
"Very good food and efficient service"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 235 Smith Street., Brooklyn, United States
"$8 for a little piece of dough with nothing inside???? I'll go on in the future. I fried an order today, the classic. With taxes over $8. It has almos..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 14 Bedford Ave, 11222-3102, Brooklyn, United States
"Disgusting perv cashier and abysmal service food"
4.8
Menu
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 1566 Flatbush Ave, 11210-3030, Brooklyn, United States
"I buy here every day sometimes 3 time per day it's that GOOD AND ADDICTIVE."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 210 Bedford Ave, Brooklyn, United States
"Solid Juice Generation location.. fresh ingredients, tasty smoothies. If you’re after a protein smoothie that tastes good this the spot. Almond milk b..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 380 Van Brunt St, 11231, Brooklyn, United States
"The best papaya salad I’ve ever had."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 571 Lorimer Street Brooklyn, NY 11211, 11211-2221, United States
"Amazing food and service! Thank you!"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 68 Willoughby St, 11201, Brooklyn, United States
"Service and atmosphere were good. The fried chicken was bland with a splash of bbq sauce on top. The chicken was also over fried and definitely wasn’t..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Brooklyn, 214 Flatbush Ave, 11217, Brooklyn, United States
"We kept walking by Corner Delhi and thinking, “we must remember this our next night out dining.” And so it went, until visiting family reminded me tha..."