Painters' Restaurant - Brookhaven

Seafood, Pizza, Continental
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Painters' Restaurant.

Painters' Restaurant

Painters' Restaurant
4.1 / 5 (5320 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Brookhaven offers 164 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $11.8.

Pampano is a popular choice for those looking for delicious Mexican seafood in midtown Manhattan. The restaurant is known for its great atmosphere, excellent food, and outstanding service. Some highlights include the shrimp quesadilla, the homemade guacamole, and chips, and the option to sit outside on the deck. While the prices may be a bit high for some, the consistency and quality of the food make it worth it for many customers. Overall, Pampano is a must-visit for those seeking a taste of Mexico in the heart of New York City.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Linda

Images

Painters' Restaurant Food Painters' Restaurant Food Painters' Restaurant Food Painters' Restaurant Food Painters' Restaurant Food Painters' Restaurant Outside Painters' Restaurant Outside Painters' Restaurant Food

Reservation request for Painters' Restaurant

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.1 / 5 from 5320 reviews

Was martin weber at Painters' Restaurant a mag?
This was our first visit to Painters Restaurant, and we were truly impressed by the menu, the quality of the food, the service, and the atmosphere. We will certainly be returning soon. View all feedback.

What rebecca boomgaarden dislikes about Painters' Restaurant:
So loud in there. The waitress said she didn't hear the appetizer order so we got it after our dinner. I guess we should have skipped it- mozzarella sticks was one chuck of mozzarella breaded and fried. It was just my husband and me dining there. We were glad no one came with us- couldn't have held a conversation. The service was quick on everything besides the appetizer. Oh well. View all feedback.

river22
08.08.2017

You know you are in a good, authentic place when the food literally transports you to your grandmother's house when you were a child. The black bean soup had this fantastic combination of ingredients that I have not found anywhere but in my grandma's kitchen. That soup, by itself, was worth the trip. The sword fish appetizer was very good and the pisco sour was fantastic (I know, pisco sour is not Mexican, but in any case, it was very refreshing and perfectly mixed). Price wise, well you are in NYC ... 'nough said.

zstoltenberg
08.08.2017

Pampano Is always excellent. Delicious and creative Mexican seafood in midtown Manhattan, One of my favorite dishes is the shrimp quesadilla--served open face with light salad, amazing sauce and perfectly cooked. It is the perfect choice for lunch. Homemade guacamole and chips, prepared however you desire is fantastic. I enjoy taking business partners here since they are always pleased with their meals. Consistency makes the difference. On nice days, consider sitting outside on the deck--you won't be sorry.

kali76
08.08.2017

Fine seafood with a Mexican twist. Good service adds to the meal. Convenient east mid town location. Worth the typical pricey NY cost.

linda
17.10.2024

Food and service was excellent It was a bit noisy but we had a nice dinner Will definitely return

wanda
17.10.2024

Food was good, the service did the best they could despite the shortage of employees. Family friendly. We will return.

  • Salads

    Sushi Tuna Asian Salad
    Sushi Tuna Asian Salad

    crispy wonton skins; mesclun greens; avocado; wasabi aioli; soy sesame dressing

    $10.0
    Grilled Watermelon Quinoa Salad
    Grilled Watermelon Quinoa Salad

    red quinoa; grilled watermelon; feta cheese; arugula; pomegranate viniagrette; balsamic; reduction

    $11.0
    Mango Avocado Pecan Goat Cheese Salad
    Mango Avocado Pecan Goat Cheese Salad

    baby spinach; red wine viniagrette

    $11.0
    The Famous Cob Salad
    The Famous Cob Salad

    chopped; romain; chicken; avocado; bacon cheddar; boiled egg; vinaigrette; tomatoes

    $11.0
  • Chomp

    French Onion Meatloaf Sandwich
    French Onion Meatloaf Sandwich

    swiss cheese; toasted garlic bread; french onion gravy

    $10.0
    Painters' Chicken Salad
    Painters' Chicken Salad
    $11.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.