1854 Pub Eatery - Broadalbin

A million times better than staying at any hotel chain. Beautiful decor, pristine rooms and a polite, friendly staff. Nice quiet area. There's a room with a cof... read more A million times better than staying at any hotel chain. Beautiful decor, pristine rooms and a polite, friendly staff. Nice quiet area. There's a room with a coffee maker and REAL cream (not that powdered junk you'd probably get elsewhere).Michele (hopefully that's spelled correctly) in housekeeping, is on top of everything! She checked daily to see if there was anything we needed and freshened up our room twice (by request). I don't mean to sound like a spoiled brat (I know how to make a bed) but there's nothing better than coming back to a freshly made bed and a clean room after a long day of being out and about while on vacation. Try requesting this in a hotel chain now (post pandemic) and see if that request even gets honored.We ate at the restaurant twice and both times the food and service were excellent. There was one waitress we had the pleasure of interacting with both times. One of the days seemed especially busy and I have never seen someone work so hard yet not show an ounce of irritation or frustration towards the customer. That, to me, speaks volumes as that type of service is very rare. I wish I got her name because she deserves to be recognized.I really can't say anything negative about this place. My experiences may seem insignificant to some but those who appreciate excellent service combined with a little something different from the norm will totally get it and should definitely check this place out.Hoping to come back next year. Thank you to The Historic Hotel Broadalbin owners and staff for your hospitality!

I really enjoy this restaurant! The food and service are excellent. My wife and I appreciate the history and ambiance here. It's conveniently located; everythin... read more I really enjoy this restaurant! The food and service are excellent. My wife and I appreciate the history and ambiance here. It's conveniently located; everything is within walking distance from the town. The food and drinks are delicious. I would rate the rooms 5 stars, the service 5 stars, and the location 5 stars as well. Hotel highlights include being romantic, quiet, kid-friendly, and offering great value.

Charming historic building. I enjoyed dinner in the pub area, accompanied by live entertainment. The room was clean and comfortable for the night. Overall ratin... read more Charming historic building. I enjoyed dinner in the pub area, accompanied by live entertainment. The room was clean and comfortable for the night. Overall ratings: Rooms: 5, Service: 5, Location: 5.

I made a dinner reservation for my husband's birthday thinking that food was going to be amazing but we got disappointed. I ordered a simple plate fish and chip... read more I made a dinner reservation for my husband's birthday thinking that food was going to be amazing but we got disappointed. I ordered a simple plate fish and chips and everything was burned and deep fried with old oil. The fish was mostly bread and my Cole salad went bad (smelled bad and tasted bad), I informed the waitress and she had the nerve to tell me that the chef tasted it and it did not have anything wrong. My son's pizza was tough and almost impossible to cut it and over oily. The prices were too high for the quality and quantity of the dishes and I was overcharged for the drinks which at that point, I paid because I just wanted to leave that place. The service was great until the waitress lied on my face but I understand she has to be on the chef's side. We all got sick by the end of the night, so we're definitely never coming back and we will make sure all our friends and family are aware so they don't go to this place.

Our cousins have stayed here several times over the past two years and they had positive things to say, so our expectations were high. Historic Hotel Broadalbin... read more Our cousins have stayed here several times over the past two years and they had positive things to say, so our expectations were high. Historic Hotel Broadalbin did not disappoint. Though the mattress in our room was a little soft for our taste, the service was top notch! We were able to sneak in for a nightcap at The bar just after closing on our first night in town, Dave (the owner) checked in with us the following afternoon to ensure we were happy with our sightseeing, and everything we tried for Saturday dinner was delicious (beans and greens soup, chicken wings, white pizza, sausage and pepperoni pizza). If you find yourself in the vicinity of Great Sacandaga Lake, you should definitely give Historic Hotel Broadalbin a try! Food drinks: Delicious! Top-notch!