The Flats Brewster

We had reservations for a 5-course New Year's Eve dinner. We only received the first 2 courses after being there for 3 hours, and the meal was complimentary.

There is always a reason behind everything that occurs.

The flash-fried Brussels sprouts are a must-have appetizer. They were able to substitute risotto for couscous on my swordfish entrée without any problem.

My two brother and spouse, my husband and I gathered for a special sibling evening. We had been there in early spring and enjoyed the service, the food and the sparse but tasteful elegance. We were very disappointed this time primarily due to the noise level. It was a busy evening and we found we could not have a full table conversation because it was so noisy. This factor alone affected everything. Service was ok but we could not hear the server. Other tables started yelling louder so they could communicate within their group. Dining in such an unpleasantly loud and disruptive environment is simply not enjoyable. I strongly urge the Flats to invest in noise baffles. Wood floors, no window treatments, no carpets,cathedral ceilings make this an echo chamber. If we had an evening that allowed dialogue my scores would be over a 4.

WE had eaten at The Flats shortly after it first opened and thought it okay Decided to try it again and was so impressed with the delicious food and service. Highly recommend.