Reviews - Kelly's Corner
Reviews summary
Nestled in Brewster, Kelly's Corner offers a blend of local charm and a more refined dining experience than a typical diner. While patrons rave about the quality of dishes like buffalo wings and strip steak, the menu occasionally falters with dry burgers and overly salty seafood. Service receives high marks for attentiveness, though some concerns about staff health practices have emerged. Despite mixed reviews on food quality, the inviting atmosphere and cozy bar make it a suitable spot for families and couples alike, especially for those looking to support local establishments. Overall, Kelly's Corner proves a hit for many diners.
Was Michael Shost at Kelly's Corner a mag?
If you're a fan of traditional Irish cuisine, you absolutely need to check out Kelly's Corner! The food is reliably delicious, and the service is consistently exceptional and professional. The staff even remembers my name and my usual order, creating a genuinely inviting atmosphere. I highly recommend trying the Kelly Burger or the Fish and Chips—both are outstanding! Plus, there’s plenty of free parking, so that's n... View all feedback.
What Stephen Gillane dislikes about Kelly's Corner:
Really good place but the place needs better sports channels and happy hour. I can't believe this place doesn't have happy hour for even the cheapest beer/ well drinks. I mean a bottle of cheap alcohol cost only $18. If they serve happy hour for $6 a drinks more people will come in! It makes sense. Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5 View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 17.08.2025
(PLEASE READ FULL REVIEW I want to preface this by saying that my hamburger was delicious, despite the fact that it was on slightly stale bread. The appetizers were good (the mozzarella sticks, which had good cheese and crunch but the breading was a little thick- and the chicken fingers, which were your typical frozen tenders. However, the quality from there really dropped. A plate of the junior nachos were ordered and they were absolutely disgusting to say the least. It was plastered with the hard, melted shredded cheese, some pieces of olives and jalapeños and was smothered with a very distasteful “beef” sauce that had no resemblance to the ground beef that was assumed to be given from the menu. Please do not order the junior nachos. The French dip was okay! The service was okay too, but the waitress admitted that one should not be ordering food items that are unpopular. The food was also pretty pricey- even after the junior nachos had to be discounted from the bill. I don’t mean to be that person- but I just wanted to put this out there. Price per person: $50–100 Food: 2 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4
Last update : 22.02.2025
Our first time at Kelly's Corner! Had strip steak and pulled pork. The food was excellent, the staff was attentive. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Good food, fine service. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5
Who lets an employee who is clearly very sick, coughing out back, blowing their nose around customers? This is bad management right here, they should have ensured she stayed home to let her get better and not endanger the public. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 3 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4
No atmosphere, food mediocre at best. Seafood pescatore so salty it was practically inedible. Couldn’t finish. Salad was wilted and on a warm plate. Previously ordered the fish sandwich which was one or two fish sticks on a bun. Terrible. A waste of money. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 2 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 2
Last update : 17.02.2025
Have consistently gotten food here. Wings are immaculate when ordered fresh. Wraps are great so is the meat selection. Would recommend.
Ordered from GrubHub before reading the reviews. My food was great ????. No complaints, potato salad was delicious and so was my chicken wrap ????. I'm very picky about my food if it's not great it goes to my dogs. Ate this all by myself ????.
I had my first visit to this restaurant, and it was wonderful. The onion rings were hot and crispy, not cold and soggy. The potato skins were equally crispy and enjoyable. The burger and fries were seasoned just right, and the roll was the perfect size for the burger. The beef stew was hearty, and the bread bowl it was served in was light and flaky. The restaurant was clean and had a delightful atmosphere that was welcoming to families.
From the moment I placed my order over the phone to the moment I picked it up, the experience was disappointing. Linda, who answered my call, was very rude. When I finally received the food, it was cold, and the sauces I was promised were missing. To make matters worse, she had difficulty processing my card, jamming it into the machine without offering any apologies or attempting to resolve the issue. I've been a loyal customer at this restaurant for years, but after tonight, neither my family nor the friends I've recommended it to will be returning. Shane, this used to be our favorite place when the previous owners were in charge.
The service staff is extremely friendly and attentive. The food is exceptional! My kids absolutely adore the hot wings. The atmosphere is really enjoyable.
Last update : 15.03.2023
Waiters and waiters are very nice and sweet. Food is excellent! My children love the hot wings. Nice ambience.
This was my first visit to Kelly's Corner, and it exceeded my expectations. The onion rings were served hot and crispy, not cold and soggy. The potato skins were also delightfully crispy. The burgers and fries were well-seasoned, and the bun was just the right size for the patty. The beef stew was hearty, and the bread bowl it was served in was light and flaky. The restaurant was clean and had a lovely family-friendly atmosphere.
Fun. Nice place. Good food. Friendly service. Wings were great. Open faced steak sandwich and meatloaf strawberry ice cream. Long Island iced tea gave nice buzz. Good parking.
I always got food here. Wings are freshly unprepared when ordering. Wraps are great, so is the meat selection. Would recommend.
I ordered from GrubHub without checking the reviews first, and I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of my food. Everything was fantastic! The potato salad was delicious, and the chicken wrap was just as good. I'm quite particular about my food—if I don’t enjoy it, it usually goes to my dogs. But in this case, I happily finished it all by myself!
