Allstarz - BORDENTOWN

Food is decent, yet very overpriced imo. If you dine with a larger group you get stuck in the side room which is not intimate, it's dark, loud, and cold! Clearly, the room is not insulated. It was a balmy 45 degree windy evening, must be trying to save a buck by not turning the heat on! Add these unpleasant factors to the fact you have the pleasure of smelling cigarette smoke since they allow for smoking on the outside of the room. Upon making reservation, we asked if they offered whole cakes (since we were celebrating a birthday), the said no. It was disclosed at that time that if we brought in an outside cake, there'd be a $3/pp as a serving fee. Ridiculous policy. I brought in cupcakes since they didn't need to be served my nieces/nephews would enjoy cupcakes! The front desk held them hostage, otherwise they'd charge the $3/pp fee-for me to serve them, not the server!! Between this greedy policy horrible atmosphere I'd highly suggest not having Jimmy's host your events.

I have extended family that visits NJ twice a year. We always plan a lunch together so we catch up. We have been meeting in the Bordentown area because it is a midway point for those driving. So six months ago we were served some undercooked food at our regular place( they did not charge us for the food and did everything reasonable to keep us happy) but we decided to try Jimmy's American Grill which is very close by. Jimmy's shares a massive parking lot with the other place. They have a grand entrance, a large bar, patio and dining room. The decor is stylish and has the preamble on a mural. There were Christmas decorations and giant poinsettia plants and holiday music playing. We received a specials menu, full menu and breakfast offerings which they serve until 2:00 on weekends. We mostly ordered sandwiches and all six of us were pleased with the food. We sat around and talked and although the server was good, I realized it had been two hours since we were served and he had yet to come by to offer us dessert. Due to the low average from Yelp reviews I was reluctant to try Jimmy's American Grill, but I am a Maverick. Yelp has even awarded me a badge that says so. I have to say I was glad I ignored the reviews. Our experience was great. As always your mileage may vary but we will most definitely be back.

Went there last night for the Super Bowl we had a party of eight adults and two high chairs. Our server was phenomenal. With order accuracy and check backs. We only ordered food from the happy hour menu like flat breads, wings, hummus and nachos it was all great. Drinks were all great as well besides the watermelon mojito. Will definitely be back.

Where to start... Jimmy's is overall pretty good. Big place, decent menu, not a bad beer and drink list. I do feel it is a bit overpriced for what it is in the area that it is in, however, that tends to keep rif raf out. Service I feel is slow, especially when busy, but last time a manager, as they should, jumped behind the bar to help. Not so much a knock on the servers because these days it seems no place has enough people to work. We do work happy hours here frequently. Mediterranean Flatbread I had last time was really good. Worth a stop

Had dinner out earlier this week and decided to check out Jimmy's American Grill. I live in the area but hadn't come to Jimmy's since they rebranded some time ago from Alstarz Sports Bar. The place is absolutely enormous and despite the packed parking lot, we were seated immediately in a large side dining room which has a second full sized bar. We had plenty of space and it was nice to not be in a crowded area. Service was great. She was busy but we always knew she hadn't lost track of us. We ordered the blackened chicken sandwich and the steak blue salad. Food was very good and overall experience assured that we'll be back again soon.