Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza - Feedback

Place was ice cold. Everyone was walking out. We could not enjoy our meal. Plus our pizza was burnt real bad. We eat there all the time and this was real bad.Wa... read more Place was ice cold. Everyone was walking out. We could not enjoy our meal. Plus our pizza was burnt real bad. We eat there all the time and this was real bad.Waitress was wearing a coat. Stated when its hot out the ac won't shut off

We're going here all the time, but today the pizza was terrible. it was understated and soggy. wound to home and heat it the next day read more We're going here all the time, but today the pizza was terrible. it was understated and soggy. wound to home and heat it the next day

Fantastic wings and great pizza. It was very crowded when we got there at 7, but emptied out by 8. read more Fantastic wings and great pizza. It was very crowded when we got there at 7, but emptied out by 8.

Can’t beat the wings, the cauliflower margherita pizza’s at Anthony’s always delicious! Service was great too. read more Can’t beat the wings, the cauliflower margherita pizza’s at Anthony’s always delicious! Service was great too.

The crust was burned. The waitress advised that this is normal as the crust is thin. read more The crust was burned. The waitress advised that this is normal as the crust is thin.

Parking: Next to a Starbucks. Both places are busy. Can be limited parking. read more Parking: Next to a Starbucks. Both places are busy. Can be limited parking.

It's an excellent choice for our monthly date nights! My wife and I both love the food, and they frequently add new items to the menu, so there's always somethi... read more It's an excellent choice for our monthly date nights! My wife and I both love the food, and they frequently add new items to the menu, so there's always something new to try. Our bartender and server, Ally B., is fantastic! She takes great care of us and knows our drink preferences without needing to ask. The entire staff is consistently friendly. Although it's a busy spot, I highly recommend it!

This is the best pizza on the island! No matter what day you go they always are so friendly and takes care of your orders. Emma makes sure she gets it perfect e... read more This is the best pizza on the island! No matter what day you go they always are so friendly and takes care of your orders. Emma makes sure she gets it perfect every time. And Jessica is the best manager we have ever experienced

We recently held a fundraiser for our Track and Field team at this restaurant, and the owners and staff were fantastic and very accommodating. Throughout the da... read more We recently held a fundraiser for our Track and Field team at this restaurant, and the owners and staff were fantastic and very accommodating. Throughout the day, we had numerous people coming and going to support us, and everyone had a great time and enjoyed the food. I highly recommend this place!

Oh little green olive, what do you say?How do you feel mr black olive?Only dismay?But why feel this way you briny hero?Champion of the salad.Oh, for there are n... read more Oh little green olive, what do you say?How do you feel mr black olive?Only dismay?But why feel this way you briny hero?Champion of the salad.Oh, for there are no olives. Yes, zero.Like my nickname in high school. zero.Like my chances of conceiving in my baron womb. Zero.Like The balance of my bank account, as I spent my last penny on pizza and salad. Zero.It’s as if this location doesn’t realize I am a close relative to Long Island’s number one customer. Heart shattered. I’ll be back, just hope there’s olives in my salad next time. By the way this location also has pizza and its fantastic.

Burnt pizza and rude staff. Makes sense that the pizza is burnt since the guy that's making the pizza is throwing bread at other staff members. read more Burnt pizza and rude staff. Makes sense that the pizza is burnt since the guy that's making the pizza is throwing bread at other staff members.

I really enjoyed the pizza at this restaurant! The menu offered a variety of interesting combinations. We decided to order half buffalo shrimp and half shrimp A... read more I really enjoyed the pizza at this restaurant! The menu offered a variety of interesting combinations. We decided to order half buffalo shrimp and half shrimp Alfredo, both of which were delicious. The strawberry lemonade was a nice, refreshing drink option. The parking lot had plenty of space and is also shared with a Starbucks.

We had a great experience ordering takeout from this restaurant! The wings were excellent, the chopped salad was delicious, and the coal fire pizza with hot hon... read more We had a great experience ordering takeout from this restaurant! The wings were excellent, the chopped salad was delicious, and the coal fire pizza with hot honey was a standout dish. I highly recommend this place!

The food was excellent and the service was exceptional at this restaurant. Emma is by far the best waitress I have encountered anywhere. She is extremely person... read more The food was excellent and the service was exceptional at this restaurant. Emma is by far the best waitress I have encountered anywhere. She is extremely personable and takes orders perfectly. She checks in regularly to ensure that everything is going well.

The food is great and so is the inside it's right next to the crappy long island MacArthur airport which frontier is trash never go anyway you should go it is g... read more The food is great and so is the inside it's right next to the crappy long island MacArthur airport which frontier is trash never go anyway you should go it is great so like always 5 STARS

What a great pizza. Even better was the friendly service I received at this location. When and if I’m ever in the Islip area again this will be on my list of pl... read more What a great pizza. Even better was the friendly service I received at this location. When and if I’m ever in the Islip area again this will be on my list of places to grab a pizza. Fresh ingredients that are full of flavor. You have to appreciate this great pizza. Give it a try, I bet you won’t be disappointed! Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30

90 bucks for 2 drinks 1 pizza, wings and 1 or 2 meatballs ridiculous. What are these places thinking. And they wonder why there was noone in there. Save your mo... read more 90 bucks for 2 drinks 1 pizza, wings and 1 or 2 meatballs ridiculous. What are these places thinking. And they wonder why there was noone in there. Save your money. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $30–50 Food: 4 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4

Great pizza spot in Islip! Definitely recommend the Hot Honey pie. Staff is very friendly, place is clean and really nice inside!! Service: Dine in Meal type: L... read more Great pizza spot in Islip! Definitely recommend the Hot Honey pie. Staff is very friendly, place is clean and really nice inside!! Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Parking space: Plenty of parking

I don't know about other locations but the pizza here is horrible taste like cardboard the worst pizza I ever had in my life. I actually threw it out. read more I don't know about other locations but the pizza here is horrible taste like cardboard the worst pizza I ever had in my life. I actually threw it out.

Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Anthonys Classic Italian Salad, Sausage Peppero... read more Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Anthonys Classic Italian Salad, Sausage Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Meatball Sausage Pizza

I am obsessed with this Chopped salad. Plus, the wings are my favorite as well. The sweet Caroline is out of this world tasty. Highly recommend. read more I am obsessed with this Chopped salad. Plus, the wings are my favorite as well. The sweet Caroline is out of this world tasty. Highly recommend.

Prosciutto and hot pepper pizza are an excellent combo 16 One Topping Pizza Large Salad Bundle was perfect for my husband and I with plenty to spare. Salad was... read more Prosciutto and hot pepper pizza are an excellent combo 16 One Topping Pizza Large Salad Bundle was perfect for my husband and I with plenty to spare. Salad was fresh and the dressing was delish.

I am very picky when it comes to pizza. I have three pizza places on Long Island that I like, now a fourth. Pizza is excellent! read more I am very picky when it comes to pizza. I have three pizza places on Long Island that I like, now a fourth. Pizza is excellent!

You call this pizza? It's Godawful and hardly coal-fired. In my opinion is it the worst dry tasting dough, paired with bad cheese and average red sauce I've eve... read more You call this pizza? It's Godawful and hardly coal-fired. In my opinion is it the worst dry tasting dough, paired with bad cheese and average red sauce I've ever tried. Never again. Ever.

The Create Your Own 16 Pizza was different and not crispy but tasted good. The Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings are much smaller and Meatballs came with no ricot... read more The Create Your Own 16 Pizza was different and not crispy but tasted good. The Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Wings are much smaller and Meatballs came with no ricotta and only 2 small focaccia. Overall quality was good but different than previous for price

We go here all the time but today the pizza was horrible. It was undercooked and soggy. Wound up bringing it home and reheating it the next day read more We go here all the time but today the pizza was horrible. It was undercooked and soggy. Wound up bringing it home and reheating it the next day

Pizza was awesome. Never a disappointment read more Pizza was awesome. Never a disappointment