Elroy's - Bloomington

Alcohol, Full, American, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Elroy's

Elroy's
3.7 / 5 (992 reviews)

Description

At this local restaurant, experiences vary widely, with service and food quality frequently debated. Some diners report unfriendly wait staff and long waits for mediocre food, expressing disappointment at what once was a favorite spot. Others, however, praise the professional service during busy nights, enjoying top-notch pub fare and a vibrant atmosphere. Highlights include a revamped outdoor dining area and standout dishes like the Buffalo grilled chicken sandwich. While some find the pizza lacking, the restaurant retains a loyal clientele drawn by the overall ambiance and occasional memorable meals. Potential diners should weigh these mixed reviews before visiting.

Last update: 02.06.2026 from: Ray

Feedback

★ 3.7 / 5 from 992 reviews
eva69
16.05.2022

What a sweat, wait staff extremely rude, waited 20 minutes to get our order taken, 40 minutes for cold fatty appetizer. then they screwed up my order and took another hour. they will save

osborne-lynch
16.05.2022

Worst food in the Bloomingotn area. Food was cold and disgusting. Used to be great and went regularly. Never agan..never.. Took my friend to show how great it was and I'll never go back. All my friends will know how bad it was. Ate a couple bites and couldn't finish and I'm not that picky. Gross...

moises-maggio
16.05.2022

Courtney from Elroy is soo excellence. So pretty and kind. Always came 2 the table w a genuine smile. Lotsa kind wisdom and advice to offer. 10/10 would definitely dine here again. I snapped a quick photo of her for reference but she didn’t want me to post it. That’s ok

ray-lemar-tree65
09.02.2024

The reviews about rude waitstaff are completely accurate. I had the unfortunate experience of being greeted by the day manager, Alex, whose rudeness within just two minutes made me want to leave without ordering. If you’re looking for friendly service, this is definitely not the place.

lee-burton-3
09.02.2024

The food was excellent, the drinks were outstanding, and the ambiance was very enjoyable. I highly recommend this place!

FAQ

You can watch major sporting events on a screen / TV right in the joint.

The restaurant also takes credit cards from the common providers for payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.