Pizzaworks - BIG PINE KEY

Delivery Services, Pizza, Cheese

Pizzaworks

Pizzaworks
3.6 / 5 (733 reviews)

Description

Nestled in a strip mall, this pizzeria captures the essence of an old-school Italian eatery, though reviews reveal a mixed bag of experiences. While many patrons rave about the delicious cheese pizza, crispy crust, and standout Stromboli, others lament issues with service and inconsistent food quality. Complaints about unresponsive phone lines and poorly executed orders are countered by enthusiastic endorsements of friendly staff and fresh ingredients. Despite the dated decor, those who appreciate a cozy, no-frills atmosphere may find comfort in the homey vibe and the potential for a delightful meal, especially when expectations align with the kitchen's strengths.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Priyanka

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 733 reviews
dennis-s-church5
19.07.2024

We had subs here. My wife loved her meatball parm, but my chicken parm was not the best I've ever had. I think it was heated in the deep fryer and tasted a little oily. We'll probably go with pizza next time, since that's what they're known for. The decor is dated and in need of freshening.

sugarloafkid
19.07.2024

Pizza was cooked great! Crispy, a little browned on the cheese. Excellent pizza, garlic knots were amazing. Will order again

gina-martinez-fish5
19.07.2024

Enjoyed my cheese pizza. Not sure why the bad reviews, mine is a good one. The cheese pizza was really good , it had a good amount of sauce and the texture was just right. I will go back.

priyanka-handa
28.08.2024

We stopped at the supercharger and, with the kids hungry for dinner, decided to drop in. The owner explained that he had four staff members call out, and he was struggling to keep up with the Friday delivery and takeout orders. Initially, he informed us that he couldn’t accommodate dine-in customers. However, noticing our urgent need for a meal and a bathroom, he offered us a table with the caveat that our food would take about 45 minutes. He quickly took the children's orders for pizza and pasta, which he delivered in under five minutes. My Greek salad with chicken and my husband’s chicken wings were both delicious, and we received our meals in under 20 minutes. The service was outstanding, and the kids loved the warm brownies that were included with their meals. Although the owner set the bar low, he far exceeded our expectations with his friendly service and delicious dinner during our trip to Key West.

doug-gossage
28.08.2024

Pizza was really good.

FAQ

The second closest stop is Greyhound Bus Lines, located 781 meters away.

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.