Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackOverall, the restaurant received mixed reviews. While some praised the food quality, atmosphere, and service, others experienced long wait times, overcooked steaks, small oysters, and poor service. Despite some negative feedback, many customers appreciated the romantic ambiance, delicious food, and attentive staff. The menu was highlighted for its variety and high-quality dishes, making it a recommended spot for a special occasion or business dinner. Despite some inconsistencies, Rudolph's seems to have potential to shine with improvements in service and food quality.
Steaks were mediocre, on the dry side. No one clearing tables, waiter handling too many tables and despite running around, would disappear for extended periods of time. The result was the worst service I have experienced in many years. On a positive note, they had a piano player/singer and a sax player that were excellent. Not enough to bring me back however.
Good food, great service but a drunken patron shouted vulgarities full blast for a half hour in upstairs dining room. Owner should have addressed this but did not. Lovely experience was almost ruined.
A gorgeous, romantic venue featuring stone walls, exposed brick, and crystal chandeliers. Just as noteworthy is the menu. The pomegranate martini was yummy, super-size shrimp cocktail was perfection. The filet mignon was served on a fluffy bed of mashed potato and surrounded by seasonal vegetables. It is hard to find a consistently good restaurant in the Mendham area. This is one of the best.
3rd visit to Rudolph's (all three times dining in the upstairs Bar Tavern ... outstanding. Look's like this will be our go to spot for local dining!
Really nice atmosphere and service bit food use to be better, and wine list was much better