Anthony's Pizza Catering

I have been let down so many times by this pizza place. I am amazed by any positive responses given we are in Jersey where some of the best pizza can be found. This place: Not fresh cheese, bad crust, meh sauce, and unpredictable by day. Even after a bad pizza experience at Anthony's we would return once in awhile only to find it was typically bad. I never understood why they didn't improve their pizza but maybe not many residents gave them feedback.

Parking for pizza place sucks! Town should designate two spots so people can pick up there food. Instead of people using spots for the Bistro, and other restaurants. Nice way to kill small business!

I didnt have the pizza so cant comment on that but got the family meal deal with caesar salad, chicken franchise and penne vodka and wow there is so much food and quite good, def going to be coming back as this was first time coming after getting mailer

Was driving North Decided to get off highway for some pizza. Meh should have just waited till I arrived up North for good pizza. Not knocking the pizza too much, but have to review. Slice small and very thin, cheese was as thin as a sheet of wax paper and see through, Sauce tasted a little bitter. They stretched a three star because the owner at counter was very nice.. and hec two slices and a soda for 5.00 was not bad deal. Still should have continued driving not worth getting off at the exit.

We loved our pie! Thank you! You can taste that they actually use fresh ingredients and not ones that have been sitting in the fridge. SincerelyThe Cafe