Casey's - Feedback

#22 - Pizza - Baxter, American, Burgers

Reviews

Overall Total Score
3.4 out of 5
Good | 134 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji

Last update : 30.09.2023

3.6 ★ from 49 reviews
cuyuna-kayaking
30.09.2023

I ordered a sandwich that was ice cold, as if it hadn't been cooked at all. When I called to inform them about the issue, they responded by saying I didn't need to be rude.

lexi-koland
30.09.2023

I have never been so disappointed. I will definitely not be returning to Casey's; it was a terrible experience.

gary-handlos
30.09.2023

I ordered a bacon cheeseburger pizza, but all I received was a pizza topped with onions, tomatoes, and cheese. There was no beef or bacon at all. I get that it can be hectic on a Friday night, but attention to detail really matters. This was one of the worst pizzas I've ever had.

emilea-ann
30.09.2023

I usually enjoy visiting Casey's, particularly the one in Baxter, but my experience today was quite disappointing due to the service I received. A staff member there, who knows me personally and seems to harbor some animosity, made some inappropriate comments. While standing with a coworker, she made sure I could hear her mention my name, saying that if I had been working the night she ordered a pizza, she would have dropped it on the floor. The other coworker who rang me up overheard this and said, "Have a good day," which prompted an angry reaction from the first employee, who questioned why she would say that to me. I was really let down by the service this morning. If personal differences can't be set aside, it's better to stay silent and remove oneself from the situation. I'm quite unhappy with how everything unfolded. When I called to report the incident, all they said was that they would discuss it with her.

ned-ryan-1
30.09.2023

This is now the third consecutive day that the hot food cabinet has been completely empty.

**Dining Dilemmas: A Mixed Bag at Local Eatery** Despite a few bright spots, recent experiences at this establishment are marred by cleanliness issues and service shortcomings. Patrons noted unkempt restrooms and litter outside. Disappointments also extended to the kitchen, where orders, such as a bacon cheeseburger pizza, were incorrectly prepared. Drive-thru service further frustrated customers; machines malfunctioned, and essential items like ice were unavailable. However, on a more positive note, the location offers 70% ethanol for E85 users, accompanied by fresh snacks and a welcoming staff. Those in need of quick meals have nearby fast food options, providing some convenience amidst the chaos.

Menu

Last update : 12.04.2023

2.6 ★ from 8 reviews
arielle-batz
12.04.2023

I stop by both Brainerd Baxter stores almost every morning, and they often don’t have breakfast pizza available. Please address this issue—we construction workers need a good meal to start our day!

merlin-mueller
12.04.2023

The restaurant was fantastic, but I had trouble finding a place to charge my 1991 Lincoln that I've converted to electric. I ended up stealing power from the neighboring building for 12 hours! On the bright side, I did manage to read my latest issue of Mad Magazine.

kwiza-flower86
12.04.2023

I ordered a bacon cheeseburger pizza, but I was disappointed to find it only had onions, tomatoes, and cheese—there was no beef or bacon at all. I understand that things can get hectic on a Friday night, but they really need to pay more attention to the details. This was one of the worst pizzas I've ever had.

rakesh-dhamla
12.04.2023

If you're traveling on E85 and find yourself at BIR, you should definitely stop by this spot. They have 70% ethanol available, and the snacks are fresh and plentiful. The staff is welcoming and always willing to assist. The restrooms are clean, and there are some quick dining options in the vicinity.

marquise34
12.04.2023

I ordered a sandwich that arrived ice-cold and appeared to be completely uncooked. When I pointed this out to the staff, they responded by saying I didn't need to be rude.

Sirved

Last update : 22.03.2025

4.1 ★ from 2 reviews
anaida-nicolescu
22.03.2025

If you're at BIR and in need of E85 fuel, this is the place to be. The ethanol concentration available here is 70%. They also serve fresh snacks, and the staff is both friendly and helpful. The facilities are well-maintained as well. Plus, there are several fast food options nearby if you're looking for a quick bite to eat.

Int Restaurants
3.5 ★ from 60 reviews
Menupix
3.9 ★ from 15 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Baxter