Cicis Pizza - Athens

Had a disappointing experience at the CiCi's in Athens. I order a pizza online and the response (automatic, I suppose) said it would be ready in 15 minutes. I arrived at the designated time and was told my pizza wasn't ready. I waited about 10 more minutes and was then told my pizza was in the oven! I complained saying I add ordered 25 minutes earlier and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. They told me that had a large order for a nearby church which was backing things up. Finally, about 35-40 minutes after I placed my online order, I got my pizza. When I got home, we discovered it the crust was still soft and almost underdone. We ate anyway. Hopefully today's experience was not typical. I may give them another chance at another time because this store is very close to where we're moving. I've eaten the buffet before and the pizzas have generally been good.

I had not been here in forever, I don't get my money's worth at buffets as I simply cannot eat that much. But I LOVE pizza! Pizza was good, I partook of the spinach and the pepperoni. No different than any of the chains. Salad was crisp and for the most part fresh. Seemed to be a good amount of choices, but I'm not a ranch, bbq, buffalo, all that jazz pizza gal. Desserts were too sugary; I tried the brownie and the apple pizza. It is ok for what it is.

Honestly, I've been going to Cicis Pizza since it has been in Athens for a long time, I was a young teen then with my living family, enjoying delicious pizza fun every moment we went. And now with all my children of my own and them eating here, feels like a bigger family more memories to enjoy with great staff, great varieties of PIZZA food. I wouldn't want anyone to miss all that????

Suppose he is the manager “Tripp” was super friendly welcome. The decor was clean, the food was great for a buffet style taste. I'm new in this area will be back.

Trippy and Sassy have done a wonderful job running this CiCi's location over the years. A few years ago they did a wonderful renovation and even added a salad dressing which tastes a lot like Olive Garden to their salad bar. They always stay on top of making sure that the right number of pizzas are hot and fresh and keep the salad bar in tip top shape. They definitely run one of the best Cici's Pizzas in the entire Southeast and we enjoy coming here!