Atco Pizza Cafe

#3 - Pizza - Atco, American, Delivery Services
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Atco Pizza Cafe

Atco Pizza Cafe
4.0 / 5 (811 reviews)

Menu

On this homepage, you will find the complete menu of Atco Pizza Cafe from Atco. Currently, there are 71 meals and drinks available.

Sally's Starr's Pizza, located in Atco, NJ, is a beloved Italian restaurant boasting an impressive average rating of 4 stars. Open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM this week, it's the perfect spot for both intimate dinners for two and lively celebrations with friends and family. Be sure to call ahead at (856) 768-1114 to reserve your table. Families will appreciate its kid-friendly atmosphere. If you're interested in exploring similar dining options, consider visiting La Frontera Mexican Restaurant or Leo's Ice Cream. We invite you to share your dining experience with others by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Christian

Images

Atco Pizza Cafe Menu Atco Pizza Cafe Inside Atco Pizza Cafe Food Atco Pizza Cafe Food Atco Pizza Cafe Food Atco Pizza Cafe Food Atco Pizza Cafe Food Atco Pizza Cafe Food

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 811 reviews

Sally's Starrs has captured the attention of local diners with its mouthwatering offerings and friendly service. While some patrons have faced delivery delays, many rave about the delicious pizza, praising both the veggie and buffalo chicken varieties. The restaurant shines with standout dishes like chicken Parmigiana and fresh rolls. Celebrations, such as birthday parties, have been enhanced by their generous large-order deals, further highlighting their community-oriented approach. Though a few diners reported issues with bland garlic bread and overly cheesy pizza, the overall consensus leans positively, making Sally's a beloved choice for both quality food and attentive service in South Jersey.

Definitely not a 1 star as listed below. Closer to a 3.5

The wings were the absolute worst wings! In some sort of salad dressing sauce! The pizza had pretty much no sause at all, and the little sauce under the cheese was thin and no flavor I will never eat there again and am suprised at how bad the wings are and its hard to make pizza bad and well it was bad!

menupix-user-beach21-2
22.10.2024

I've never been disappointed here. The chicken Parmesan is outstanding, the sandwiches are delicious, and the service is incredibly fast. Their mozzarella sticks are exceptional. I won’t order takeout from anywhere else, and the staff is both friendly and appreciative. I wholeheartedly give this place 5 stars.

christian-conner-fer
25.03.2025

Terrible delivery service. i ordered 1 thing and they said 25-30 minutes. it took over a hour before i called then they said oh sorry it?s busy. i drive by 5 minutes later there was 2 cars in the parking lot.

travis-torres-mushro
25.03.2025

Usually i will order from Gallery Pizza but i thought i would give Sally?s a try being that i?m new to the area.. called around 5:11 to order a simple large pizza well done .. i?m maybe 2 miles down the road .. no pizza and it?s been over an hour .. so icall the girl puts me on hold and gets back to tell me the pizza left and apologized .. i call back 20 minutes later as it?snow 1 hour and a half late.. the girl puts me on hold and finally gets back on the phone to say the pizza went ?missing? ?andthey?ll remake it now? no thanks i?ll take a refund ?which they could barley figure out by the way?.. safe to say i?ll stick toordering from Gallery pizza !

  • Brick Oven Pizza

    Pizza & 13 Wings
    Pizza & 13 Wings
    $21.4
    Extra Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach Or Cheese
    Extra Sausage, Bacon, Ham, Pepperoni, Spinach Or Cheese
    $3.0
  • Salads

    Caiden Salad
    Caiden Salad
    $7.1
  • Chicken Specials

    Spinach Mozzarella Chicken
    Spinach Mozzarella Chicken
    $13.1
  • Soups And Salads

    Chef Salad Hoagie
    Chef Salad Hoagie
    $7.7
  • Morning Starters

    Country Ranch Chicken
    Country Ranch Chicken
    $13.1

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.