Reviews
What User likes about Maine Black Bear Seafood Co:
This is the best seafood in the area, hands down. I won't even consider ordering fish anywhere else. Bruce is like the funny, cantankerous uncle I always wished for: he speaks his mind, doesn't beat around the bush, and cooks up the most amazing seafood in the entire Catskills. And his dog is just too cute - seeing them both at the market always puts a smile on my face. This place is a hidden gem in every way, from t... View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Maine Black Bear Seafood Co:
This restaurant claims to be open until 9 o'clock, but on two occasions when I attempted to visit, it was already closed before 8 o'clock. They should only advertise their hours accurately on Google and on their door. I will not be attempting to visit again. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I visited this restaurant once with a friend and have been hooked ever since. I loved the great atmosphere and delicious food and drinks. Excellent job.
This is the best seafood in the area, hands down. I won't even consider ordering fish anywhere else. Bruce is like the funny, cantankerous uncle I always wished...
read moreBest place to get fresh fish. Just leave some for me!
Don't let the exterior fool you. The seafood is great, friendly service but remember to bring your own wine. We try and come here whenever we are in the area. H...
read moreThis spot offers amazing service as well as tasty food. One of my favourite places in the area. The meals served quickly and the prices are fair. Highly recomme...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreNestled in the Catskills, this unassuming seafood restaurant is a hidden gem that captivates patrons with its delicious offerings and welcoming atmosphere. While its hours may be inconsistent, the culinary experience—led by the charismatic Bruce—is unmatched. Guests rave about the garlic-infused seafood, with standout dishes like the lobster sandwich earning high praise. The quirky decor adds charm to the casual setting, complemented by friendly service. Diners are encouraged to bring their own wine, enhancing the laid-back dining experience. For seafood lovers, this spot comes highly recommended, promising a delightful meal and a warm, inviting ambiance.
The best lobster I’ve ever had, love love the way they make you feel like family
It's been a while for us. The lobsters were awesome.
Fantastic fresh Seafood, friendly quaint atmosphere, great service. Has become my favorite Restaurant in the area.
We love this gem of a place! Always great and fresh lobster.
Food was amazing, I had lobster that basically fell out of its shell. Great atmosphere and delicious food.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreOnly a seafood market now. Owner says he stopped cooking the seafood since the pandemic
Lobster was amazing and our waitress was really nice!
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more