Hometown Desserts - Anna Maria

We love the peanut butter pie. Our favourite. Be good to offer one with oreo crust. Next best is the orange cake. It is awesome! The chocolate is also awesome and so is the strawberry. However the lemon is flavourless. Customer service could improve...the young girl serving us was always in a hurry, and one time refused to accommodate us with orange cake slices even though there were orange cakes in the fridge that could have been sliced up. It was 2 in the afternoon, so still a lot of time to sell more orange cake slices the rest of the day. A big however.....coffee is Kureg but u r charged barista pricing!!! Signifying this would b upfront as I find it deceiving and a rip off.

Cutest bakery at Anna Maria Island! Great food and prices. Tried the blackberry lemonade and the key lime coconut cake. Both were great!

Key lime coconut cake was very moist. It be better if it had some lime zest in the Coconut frosting a little more lime flavor.

Delicious Capuchino! Hot and strong! They have the best lemon and coconut cake we ever tried! The blueberry and maple and figs scones are very good too.

We stopped in because of all of the great reviews and were glad we did! We had to try a few items so we got the Key Lime pie, Key Lime coconut cake, a bourbon pecan pie bar and a salted caramel praline brownie. I really wanted to try the cake first so we did lol. It was so yummy! Moist but not wet if that makes sense. Great flavor and understand why so many love it! The key lime pie was the best we had while visiting. Both the bar and brownie were delicious too! Service was awesome as well. The ladies there were so nice and even gave us lunch suggestions to try. We’ll definitely be back if we ever return to the island! Give them a try! You’ll be glad you did!!