Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Tom Hoos likes about Sheridan's Lodge Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews:
First time going here despite being 10 minutes away and hearing rave reviews. Food was excellent. I had the traditional fried calamari which was very good and seasoned perfectly. The Ribeye steak was cooked perfectly medium rare with great flavor. The baked potato was kind of lack luster even for a potato, but it was fine. Overall plenty of food and fair prices despite rising food costs. My buddy had the fish and chi... View all feedback.
What Noelle Incorvaia doesn't like about Sheridan's Lodge Phone Number, Reservations, Reviews:
I was very disappointed with my dinner tonight. Everything was very greasy. The waiter was very nice very accommodating. I also ordered an apperoll spritz Which was very weak and was not made properly. I was very disappointed tonight. I usually am very happy with the meals. I had fried fish and chips and my husband got a cheeseburger and both were extremely greasy. View all feedback.
Was there for a small event. Food was good, staff was attentive and prices were reasonable.
My all time fav lunch spot, great place to watch the games as well. Feels like home, burgers are always perfectly cooked and so juicy! If you are a craft beer lover this is your place! Best service, everyone is treated like family
You would be hard pressed to find a decent restaurant in Sussex County, NJ. Sheridan's is no exception. Two of us went in for appetizers and drinks this Saturday evening. The best part of the meal was the free bar pretzels you get when you sit down. After placing our order it was 30 minutes before food arrived. On our order were Nachos with Chicken and Shrimp Quesadilla. Perhaps ordering Mexican inspired food at a non-Mexican restaurant was not the best idea. The Nachos were topped with foul smelling chicken that was extremely dry and flavorless. I immediately sent it back for fear of getting sick. The shrimp quesadilla was so soggy it could only be eaten with a knife and fork. Who eats finger food with a knife :fork? Such a shame for a place that once was one of those decent, hard pressed to find places.
The boom boom shrimp has just the right amount of heat. The fish and chips are good!
This is a great part of our community, a place where you can get a great meal, excellent cocktail and are as if among friends or family. The team are always caring and happy to accommodate. Chicken pot pie is and always is the best!! Cocktails are awesome and during covid they made the takeout extraordinary and simple.
Full Menu
Download MenuStarters & Salads
Fish Dishes
Chicken Dishes
Sauces
More information
QR-code link to the menu
