Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute FeedbackWilly McCoy's offers a mix of experiences, from poor seating and service to delicious food and attentive staff. The menu has its highs and lows, with some items lacking in quality and portion size. The atmosphere is a blend of rustic charm and worn-down aesthetics. The restaurant shines in its attentive service, delicious food like the Walleye sandwich, and options for private events. While some dishes may disappoint, the overall experience is bolstered by friendly service and a fun ambiance. Willy McCoy's is a good choice for those seeking a lively, welcoming atmosphere with opportunities for improvement in certain areas.
Amazing food and service.....we had our granddaughters with us and they were so nice to them....our waitress was amazing as well!!! We will definitely be going back!!!
Very spacious bar area with nice ambiance and beautiful woodwork. Had Firecracker Shrimp and Seared Steak Bites for appetizers. Shrimp were very large and perfectly cooked with a pretty spicy sauce..firecracker indeed! Beautiful plating on this too. Steak bites could have had a little more sear but were also very tasty and juicy. Wished the onion straw garnish was more to the side so as not to hide the nice chunks of steak. Partner's Walleye Sandwich had an enormous crispy and tender fillet. Great value considering prices elsewhere. Our Cuban Sandwiches had a generous amount of tender, well seasoned pulled pork. Could have been a bit better with a Panini press and ciabatta bread. Really had a surprisingly tasty coleslaw. The Sweet Heat Chicken Sandwich had a sauce similar to the Firecracker Shrimp which paired very well with the apple to tame it down a bit. Enormous bacon strip!! Had the Philly Cheesesteak Burger recently and although I expected shaved beef, the pieces were very tender and flavorful. Stuffed with cheese curds and queso sauce, it was tremendously satisfying. If you love a meaty burger, this is for you!! Was extremely busy and was very impressed with how quickly our food came out.
We've been here probably three times a month for the last six months and it has NEVER failed to be anything but spectacular! Service is always excellent even though they are always busy! My husband (a self claimed cheeseburger expert) says this is the best cheeseburger he's EVER had. He gets the blue cheese irish whiskey burger every time. I like the fajita flatbread, the mac and cheese, the southwest wrap, the fish and chips, and the we both LOVE the cheese curds and tator tots! Bathrooms are always clean. 10/10 dinner date!
Food and service were both great! My son has gluten allergies and they were very accommodating with that and have some of the best GF pizza he's ever had
We love going here on Mondays for their 1/2 price burgers. We'd pay full price any day but this is a special treat. The burger is always perfect. We also eat there on other days and have consistently had great food and service.
Full Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7d724/7d72428bbc22f8ccbf24a7defa2d18924ea3711c" alt="QR-Code zur Speisekarte von Willy McCoys Andover"