Quesadillas - Amherst

#14 - Mexican - Amherst, Casual, Full
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Quesadillas

Quesadillas
3.8 / 5 (189 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Quesadillas from Amherst contains about 248 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $10.3 for a dish / drink.

**Restaurant Review: A Mixed Bag with Highlights** Nestled in the heart of Amherst, this restaurant offers a vibrant atmosphere and a friendly staff, but experiences can vary. While some diners praise the flavorful, authentic Mexican dishes like chicken chimichangas and generous quesadilla portions, others lament the decline in food quality, bland flavors, and service hiccups, especially during busy times. Issues with order mix-ups have led to frustrating experiences for some takeout patrons. Despite these setbacks, the establishment remains a local favorite for its festive ambiance and affordable drink specials, especially the popular 99-cent margaritas on Tuesdays. A place worth trying, but with cautious expectations.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Michael

Images

Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Food Quesadillas Inside

Feedback

★ 3.8 / 5 from 189 reviews

Was jeffrey h at Quesadillas a mag?
If you want real Mexican food this is the place. Excellent food great drinks and good people working there. They have a nice patio when the weather is permitting. Located right across from the Amherst theater its a little known local treasure that's been there for years. If you like really hot food try the chili Colorado chili rojo extra hot and some of their hot salsa. View all feedback.

What P W dislikes about Quesadillas:
Not a bad place, when I was in there the food was plane and needed more season. First beer I had tasted old, the second was better. Really nice owner and great employees. Family friendlyFood: 3/5 View all feedback.

jeffrey-27
02.08.2023

If you want real Mexican food this is the place. Excellent food great drinks and good people working there. They have a nice patio when the weather is permitting. Located right across from the Amherst theater its a little known local treasure that's been there for years. If you like really hot food try the chili Colorado chili rojo extra hot and some of their hot salsa.

tyler-558
02.08.2023

Super fast service!! We stopped by for a quick lunch and were in and out in under 30. Atmosphere was pretty cool, but let’s be real, we went for the food!I got their new tacos aztecas and it was incredible!! I loved the chorizo and chicken combo. Plus whatever sauce they put on it was super tasty!Chips were okay, but salsa was great!!!My buddy ordered chicken, rice and avocado and he said his food was awesome!!!Prices were reasonable and I highly recommend checking this place out.

david-1278
02.08.2023

Like many restaurants, this one is struggling with a staffing shortage. The wait time for dining in was longer than expected, and the quality of the food has declined—it's disappointing because it used to be excellent. The plate was excessively hot to touch, even though it wasn't a skillet, which left the rice and refried beans hard and clumped together. On a positive note, the drinks were good, and the waiter did his best to provide quality service.

michael-k-grass1
18.05.2024

Absolutely the worst first-time experience! If I could give zero stars, I would. My wife and I placed an Uber Eats order, and when it arrived, I only received one of the burritos, so my wife had to drive there to sort it out. When she arrived, they remade the order, only for it to be wrong again. Now, my wife is driving back for a second time to get them to fix it. We ordered hours ago, and we still haven't eaten because they keep messing up our order. I wouldn't recommend this place to anyone who's hungry; they've only proven they can serve disappointment. Thanks for nothing. To make matters worse, when my wife called to let them know about the mistake, they questioned if we were sure it was their error and implied we were just trying to get free food, despite us returning all the incorrectly filled orders. This has been the worst experience ever!

mary-c-chef59
18.05.2024

We absolutely love the quesadillas at this restaurant! The food is incredible, always served fresh and hot. There’s a fantastic selection of options to choose from. The service is excellent, and the staff are consistently friendly and professional. My personal favorites are the Chiori Pollo and the Potato Enchiladas. You definitely won't be disappointed!

  • Combo

    Combo Tapatio
    Combo Tapatio
    $15.2
  • Entrées

    16Oz Guac
    16Oz Guac
    $16.3
  • Quesadillas

    Amherst Quesadilla
    Amherst Quesadilla
    $13.2
  • Traditional Meals

    Pina Loca Texana
    Pina Loca Texana
    $17.2
    Steak Vampiro
    Steak Vampiro
    $17.2
  • Fajitas

    Tradicional Fajitas For 1
    Tradicional Fajitas For 1
    $17.2

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.