My Tomato Pie - Amherst

#10 - Vegetarian - Amherst, Italian, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +17168380969
Reservation
Reservation request for My Tomato Pie.

Menu

The menu of My Tomato Pie from Amherst includes 54 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $7.9. You can view the categories on the menu below.

The restaurant offers a diverse and delicious menu, winning patrons over with standout dishes like their renowned tomato pie and portobello mushroom wrap. While the food delights, service consistency varies; some guests have noted feeling rushed by servers despite ample dining hours. Instances of confusion, such as closed pickup orders and lackluster apologies, marred the experience for a few. However, the atmosphere is generally warm, with friendly staff and efficient service. Patrons appreciate the restaurant's community involvement and accommodating policies, making it a potential favorite for those looking for great food in a welcoming environment.

Last update: 12.12.2025 from: Marilyn

Images

My Tomato Pie Food My Tomato Pie Food My Tomato Pie Inside My Tomato Pie Inside My Tomato Pie Menu My Tomato Pie Menu My Tomato Pie Food My Tomato Pie Food

Reservation request for My Tomato Pie

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 2292 reviews

Was User at My Tomato Pie a mag?
Recently a sample dinner was held in the small banquet room. The food was excellent and the service was fantastic. And the price was very reasonable. I would recommend everyone holding an intimate banquet. View all feedback.

What User dislikes about My Tomato Pie:
I placed an online order for pickup at this restaurant. They charged my credit card, sent me a confirmation email, and then texted me to let me know my food was ready. However, when I arrived to pick it up, the restaurant was closed! The next day, I received a call explaining that they had made a mistake and promised to refund my credit card. There was no formal apology given. Overall, a disappointing experience. View all feedback.

Recently a sample dinner was held in the small banquet room. The food was excellent and the service was fantastic. And the price was very reasonable. I would recommend everyone holding an intimate banquet.

The food here is exceptional, with a diverse menu that has something for everyone. There's plenty of parking available, and I've never had to wait for a spot. Service is fast, and dishes quickly make their way to your table. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive. I also attended a baby shower here, and the team was wonderful. Additionally, they partner with the WNY Alzheimer's chapter and donate a portion of their sales to support this cause each year.

I'm here several times with friends. The food is just fantastic. The servers are wonderful and friendly. I love this place.

marilyn-w-fox62
Marilyn 26.02.2024 - 19:46

The food here is fantastic and the portions are quite generous. I ordered a portobello mushroom veggie wrap, and it was truly delightful. I could only manage to eat half of it. I would definitely...

maria-w-firefighter9
Maria 26.02.2024 - 19:46

The food is fantastic, and the service is excellent! We always enjoy our visits here. Be sure to try the tomato basil soup—it's absolutely delicious!

  • Beers On Tap

    7. Molson Canadian
    7. Molson Canadian
    $5.0
  • Beer On Tap

    10. Double Jusey
    10. Double Jusey
    $5.5
    13. Allegheny Ipa
    13. Allegheny Ipa
    $5.5
    14. Ruby Red Kölsch
    14. Ruby Red Kölsch
    $5.5
    15. Maine Blueberry
    15. Maine Blueberry
    $5.5
    16. Hazy Little Thing
    16. Hazy Little Thing
    $5.5

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.