Reviews
What E Bou doesn't like about The Lobster Roll Amagansett:
Was just in there 2 days ago and it was a complete disaster. The lobster was rubbery, making it almost inedible. To make matters worse, the wine tasted like it was five years old and had gone bad. When I brought these issues up to our server, he dismissively said, I see, and rolling of the eyes (beyond arrogant and didn 't offer any solution or apology. This was the most ridiculous experience I 've ever had, with bot... View all feedback. What User likes about The Lobster Roll Amagansett:
Best lobster role we tried on our trip through NY, Mass and Maine, so we say something. Your hot lobster roll can't beat! Paired with Hearty Manhattan Chowder is *Koch?s kiss*. Only what we didn't have was the buffalo Calamari. I think we only enjoy Calamari prepared the southern, kalabash way. Don't miss a stop here. You are also a dog friendly! View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I've always wanted to visit this place ever since I saw "The Affair." The food and service were fantastic. It's dog-friendly, so we enjoyed sitting on the patio...
read moreThe lobster rolls are fantastic! The atmosphere is lovely, the staff is friendly, and the food quality is excellent. However, I found the prices a bit high comp...
read moreI had a wonderful experience at this restaurant. The food was delicious and reasonably priced, and the service was excellent. The atmosphere was pleasant as wel...
read moreI would say in total I would give this a 3.5 for the food, but have them 4 stars because of the atmosphere and service. The lobster roll and fries were $41, and...
read moreFirst time visiting the Hamptons and craving lobster. My guy found your place and I’m like why not. The waitress was super nice. The margaritas was amazing! I o...
read moreDuring our trip through New York, Massachusetts, and Maine, we found the best lobster roll here—truly unbeatable! It pairs perfectly with the hearty Manhattan c...
read moreDuring a long girls' weekend on the island, we were returning from the Montauk Lighthouse on a chilly day, looking for something to warm us up. That's when we d...
read moreNot a huge seafood fan, but I stopped by this place due to the large crowd. We tried the fried shrimp and a lobster roll, and they were good. However, the $80 b...
read moreThe place for Lobster roles. Either in the traditional or hot lobster, you can't go wrong. The Clam Chowder and fish and chips were also really good. Really nic...
read moreServers are friendly and the menu is extensive. Highly recommend the hot lobster roll, though the traditional cold one is solid as well. Onion rings are very oi...
read more