Coche Comedor - Amagansett

The food was quite delicious. We definitely appreciated that this was one of the only spots open during the off period. I had been here a few years ago when it was being renovated to this restaurant. I had almost used it as a film location, but decided for something closer to oakdale. The staff was so friendly here.

Food is mediocre and over priced. Portions are small. The kicker for me was how rude they were when I used the bathroom while getting dinner another time at their restaurant next store (which doesn 't have a bathroom). Way to treat your customers.. I explained that my hands had dirt on them and there was no where else to wash my hands and was told not my problem. The restaurant was empty.

Very impressive. Terrific service and menu was very varied, fresh and delicious. Mezcal options were broad. I like this place, indoors or outdoors. Bringing my whole family this week. Yum

Coche Comedor apparently chose to be closed on Sunday, February 11th, but didn't bother to let the public know. I called the number and heard the outgoing message on Sunday afternoon, saying that they were open for dinner beginning at 5. Even on Yelp, it says they are open on Sundays. To all those who showed up for dinner only to find the restaurant dark, I'm sorry for the inconvenience and lack of consideration of management.

Dined on a Wed. Arrived a little before 6 and there was no one else indoors. After about 15 minutes the place was packed! Had a watermelon margarita. I don't recommend getting a salted rim; it took away from the flavor of the drink. A sugar/sweet rim would probably be better. Mom has the flamingo and loved it. We started with the queso. My parents loved it the most and they never indulge in starters. It's not your typical bowl of melted cheese. For dinner mom and I split the whole roasted chicken and it was twice as much food as we needed. It was nicely cooked, very moist, and just as good the next day!