Clam At Napeague - Amagansett

If you're heading to Montauk, be sure to stop by the Clam Bar. It's best to avoid peak lunch hours on weekends (12 PM to 2 PM), as it tends to get quite crowded and parking can be tricky. The staff is always efficient and friendly, regardless of how busy they are. Their lobster roll is a consistent delight, packed with fresh lobster and priced at market value. The clam strips are a must-try as well; they're fried to perfection, with juicy mussels inside. If you're in the area, I highly recommend making a stop here.

Without a doubt, this is the best Lobster BLT sandwich I've ever had. The restaurant offers plenty of seating options; you can choose to sit at a table, eat at the counter, or stand at a table. Parking can be a bit challenging, but there are shoulder parking spots available—just be sure not to park in the bike lane. The menu features a wide range of options to choose from.

This is likely the best fish restaurant in the area. The prices are great, the staff is friendly, and the service is quick. Be sure to try their New England-style clam chowder; you won't regret it! Also, they offer the best cold lobster salad sandwich in Long Island—I'm sure it would be delicious served hot as well.

Some of the best seafood I had. The tuna steak on salad was well done. My wife loved her lobster and granddaughter loved the fish and chips. I wish we lived closer and could stop more often

Great experience! Had lunch at the counter on Friday afternoon headed back from Montauk.. The lobster roll and the tuna bites were amazing. The lobster roll was packed with lobster, one of the best portions I’ve seen. Additionally, the staff was very friendly and kind, wish I could remember tue two gentlemen’s names who helped us.. What a different experience than two weeks before eating at a.k.a. lunch across the street.. Highly recommend this place you won’t be disappointed !