The Catty Corner Neighborhood Pub And Pie

The food was very good, it was only a bit too salty. They were friendly. It wasn't very busy when we were there.Food: 4/5

It’s a nice place with great food and friendly staff .....very clean and well kept...we drive out of our way to eat and enjoy the great environment .......stop and try it ...you won’t regret it ....if you like a good pizza it’s the place you must go and try .wings are very tasty and the burgers are greatFood: 5/5

We love coming to the Catty corner! It’s close to our house and has great daily specials! We love the wing and Stromboli night, such a good deal for great food!! The pickle pizza is delicious as well!Food: 5/5

Went to Catty Corner Neighborhood Pub Pie on Friday hoping for some good food. I usually only get a couple of slices of pizza but decided to try something new this time. I ended up ordering a catty melt, well done, with no onions or peppers. They messed up my order and still gave me onions and pepper. I wasn’t too upset, it’s not like i’m allergic to them, and it’s something I could easily take out of my burger. Thank goodness they accidentally added that because if not I could have easily BROKEN my teeth. I opened my burger to pick out the onions and peppers but never could have imagined what else could have been on my burger. A SCREW was sitting right inside. I took my burger to the owner, he apologized and said he would bring out a new burger for me. The new burger was thankfully screw free but they rushed it out so fast that it was no where near well done, it was extremely pink. I took the burger back again and only then did he mention the burger would be taken off the bill. Now on my third burger, I guess they would rather be safe than sorry, they took off the mushrooms from my burger and my burger was so “well done” that it was stiff. So not only did my first burger have onions, peppers, and a SCREW in it, the second one was severely undercooked, and the third one was overcooked and missing toppings that I wanted in it. Definitely won’t be visiting again, not even for their pizza.I also want to add that our server was extremely helpful and more apologetic than the owner himself.

We got a large meat calzone and it was truly excellent! The filling went literally all the way to the corners where as so many other places tend to be 60% dough. We have finally found a pizza place worth being our go-to spot. Every employee I spoke to while in the restaurant was super nice too. We also got wings and they were perfect, not dry or anything. Can't wait to try some other menu items.