Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Zachary Lange likes about New York Pizza Plus:
I usually don't leave a review until I've ordered from a place multiple times. We've gotten takeout about a dozen times now. The pizza and entrees are good. Their red sauces are all very good which is important to me at an italian restaurant. Another important thing is they're super consistent. The dishes have been good quality every time and not once has anything been incorrect or missing in any of my orders. The st... View all feedback.
I bought my new bf to dinner. He loved it as much as I do. Great place!
Litteraly call me ITALIAN for the way I inhaled this food. Everything they have is so good and my family loves the seafood bisque Fridays. Literally felt like I was in Italy and everyone is very nice. The photo is the Roma spinach pizza and 10/10 would recommend!!! It’s a bit pricy but the quality makes up for it.
It has been a little while since we visited here, but wow! The service was great and the food was amazing! We spilt the California salad and the Chicken Oscar. Which allowed us to enjoy dessert! Turtle cheesecake and chocolate canoli! Yum!
Best Pizza in Alachua! Truly everytime I order pizza here it is done perfectly and delicious. We have not dined in and we have only ever ordered pizza...although we are ready to try some of their pasta!
Traveling back home from visiting friends in Florida. What a great find… food was delicious (steak cheese sub and pepperoni pizza). Large portions their garlic biscuits were yummy too. Relaxing atmosphere in main dining area. Our server was Aiden he was polite, helpful friendly. We would definitely recommend going there. Thank you for such an enjoyable experience!
Full Menu
Download MenuDessert
Pizza
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
