Reviews - Casey's
Reviews summary
Nestled in a convenience-store setting, this spot earns praise for surprisingly excellent pizza, brisket and hot breakfast sandwiches, plus friendly, hands-on staff and competitive fuel prices. Value-minded travelers and quick-meal seekers appreciate the offerings, but experiences vary: cleanliness and sandwich availability are inconsistent, online ordering and scheduled pick-ups can be unreliable, and some packaged items are pricey. Great for fast, affordable pizza and fuel stops, though customers should be cautious when planning timed or specialty orders.
Was Kevin L at Casey's a mag?
The staff at this location is a fantastic group who really make you feel at home. They take great pride in their work, and it truly shows. The manager isn't hesitant to pitch in and ensure everything is running smoothly. The brisket pizza has quickly become my new favorite, along with the hot breakfast sandwiches. Additionally, this is one of the cleanest Casey's locations I’ve ever visited. View all feedback.
What Ben Knight dislikes about Casey's:
This is the dirtiest store I have ever seen. All the ice cream is in boxes instead of being on racks where customers can easily access it. Plus, the cereal costs a whopping 8 dollars a box. View all feedback.
Reviews from various users
Last update : 14.10.2023
This place offers very competitive prices on fuel and store items. Their pizzas are surprisingly much better than what you would expect from a gas station. The staff is always welcoming and friendly.
The staff at this location is a fantastic group who really make you feel at home. They take great pride in their work, and it truly shows. The manager isn't hesitant to pitch in and ensure everything is running smoothly. The brisket pizza has quickly become my new favorite, along with the hot breakfast sandwiches. Additionally, this is one of the cleanest Casey's locations I’ve ever visited.
Last update : 14.10.2023
This store claims it’s 24 hours and the sign on highway also says so! Don’t waste your time driving 3 miles to this store off of i70. They were closed at 4:30 am! No gas OR food.
I had went in and ordered sub sandwiches yesterday on the 2nd of July 2022 and the very next day called to make another order for sub sandwiches and was told that there sandwiche station had been down and not working so they are not making sub sandwiches so I asked how long has it been down and the person had said for the last 2 weeks. How can that be if I just ordered sub sandwiches the day before. So eather they just did not want to make sub sandwiches and lyed to me saying it has been down for 2 weeks. Eather way it's not cool I'm very disappointed
I ordered two Italian subs with all veggies, pepper jack cheese, toasted bread today. I get it 15 min late. Not veg toasted or cheese just meat. This was all online. Very disappointing. Not the delivery drivers fault. Casey's needs to get it in gear and fix their online system .
Always something out or not in stock (ice cream, coffee, soft drinks).and for what they charge, you'd think they'd get it straight. Also, their sweet tea tastes like pure hot garbage.. oy sweet and definitely a nasty Great Value type tea quality taste so don't waste your money on it. Also at lunch and no sandwich orders being taken/made.
I placed my order more than an hour in advance, but when I arrived to pick it up, I was told they hadn't even started preparing it. Apparently, they only begin cooking at the scheduled pick-up time. What's the point of having a designated pick-up time if you can't actually pick up your order for the event it's intended for? To make matters worse, the restaurant wasn't even busy—just seems like they were being lazy.
