Reviews
What Joshua M doesn't like about Vine Street Café:
Food was pretty good for the most part, some definitely better than others. But we showed up at 530 as a party of 7 and the service was horribly slow. Incredibly slow. They kept saying things were backed up — the bar was backed up so the drinks would be a while. The kitchen was backed up so the food would be a while. Meanwhile, parties seared after us received their food and drinks well before we did. It was a dinner... View all feedback. What Bud D likes about Vine Street Café:
I wish there were six stars with which to rate this restaurant. Nothing on the east end of Long Island compares to it for quality of food. It's like Stone Creek when they were just getting a name for themselves. The building is modest but mostly hand built and creative and cool. The staff are talented, devoted, hard working, proud, and yet quiet and modest. So secluded and hard to get to, being out on Shelter Island,... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Amazing food and service…Great restaurant!! The Best in the East of the island!!! Period!!!! Would recommend to anyone!!!!
I wish there were six stars with which to rate this restaurant. Nothing on the east end of Long Island compares to it for quality of food. It's like Stone Creek...
read moreBest restaurant on Shelter Island hands down. Great food and great service. Spicy Tuna tacos are killer!
Great meal. Never rushed. Found selections to be great combinations.
Lovely to be back. Still delicious. Still cozy. Feels like family
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more