Full menu with prices & pictures
Bagel Jay's Bakery C... 100 Plaza Dr A, 14221, Williamsville...
(+1)7166391000
(+1)7165681131
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Bagel Jay's Bakery C...
The place from Williamsville offers 33 different menus and drinks on the menu at an average $5.0.
What Matt In Williamsville likes about Bagel Jay's Bakery Cafe:
I completely disagree with Dawn's opinion. The bagels here are the same size but much fresher. Since it's a local business rather than a chain, the prices are understandably higher. I really enjoy the Sahlen's ham sandwich on an everything bagel. Keep an eye out for coupons in mailers like Valpak to get the best value. I would definitely recommend this place to everyone! View all feedback.
What Rhett Auer doesn't like about Bagel Jay's Bakery Cafe:
Good bagels but slowest service I’ve ever experienced. Got here at 8am, only one other car in the drive thru and waited 5 minutes just to give my order, another 10 to receive it. Figured they’d be busy inside but when I pulled up but it was empty with 6+ employees inside just standing around. All the employees are either under 21 or over 65 and rarely are orders without mistake. They really need to optimize the drive... View all feedback.
Every time I’ve visited Bagel Jay’s, their bagels have been excellent, whether enjoyed on a san...
During the travel hockey season, this is our go-to spot when they’re on the road. It tends to b...
I completely disagree with Dawn's opinion. The bagels here are the same size but much fresher....
I had a bagel with some cheesy goodness alongside a cup of tea. The bagel was delicious, and th...
Best bagels in New York! They have fantastic breakfast bagel sandwiches, and their tuna melt ba...
Seafood With Vegetables