Casey's - Wheatfield
Casey's
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Casey's in Wheatfield. At the moment, there are 11 meals and drinks on the menu.
Casey's in Wheatfield, IN, is a beloved American restaurant with a welcoming atmosphere and an average rating of 3.6 stars. Open from 4:00 AM to 11:00 PM, it's a great spot to satisfy any craving, with a diverse menu that includes delicious vegetarian options. Looking to plan your visit? Feel free to call ahead at (219) 956-3022 to check on wait times or reserve a table. If you're in the mood for something similar, don't forget to explore the offerings at Quiznos and Hop Quest Brewing Company. We’d love to hear about your favorite dishes, so be sure to leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
This neighborhood pizza spot serves budget-friendly pies and strong coffee, beloved by regulars for its friendly barista and popular menu (pepperoni, sausage, taco pizza, wings). However, patrons report frequent delays, understaffed evenings, order mistakes and occasional undercooked specialty pizzas. Service quality is inconsistent—some staff are welcoming while others appear overwhelmed—so it’s a good choice for casual coffee or relaxed takeout but not for time-sensitive events. Parking is ample and free.
I come here all the time every time I order pizza they tell me 30-35 mins which is long as it is and it usually ends up being 45-50mins. Always show up when they say it will be done and it's never done in time.
This is definitely the worst casey's I've been to. Normally casey's is a nice gas station to stop at get a snack and a drink usually at a good price too. They also tend to be clean and with nice staff. The kitchen staff were rude when I came through late one night and wanted a pizza they said 45 minute wait that's insane a normal casey's wait would be like 15 minutes. I didn't seem to be the only person who had this issue. then when I showed up to get my order it wasn't ready yet and I was told another 30 minutes I just cancelled the order.
This is definitely the worst casey's I've been to. Normally casey's is a nice gas station to stop at get a snack and a drink usually at a good price too. They also tend to be clean and with nice staff. The kitchen staff were rude when I came through late one night and wanted a pizza they said 45 minute wait that's insane a normal casey's wait would be like 15 minutes. I didn't seem to be the only person who had this issue. then when I showed up to get my order it wasn't ready yet and I was told another 30 minutes I just cancelled the order.
Got to the store when they said it would be done and waited another 30 minutes for our pizza and sides. The girl up front was very nice but one of the guys supposed to be working/cooking was literally just standing back there talking. Very ridiculous.Several other people were waiting forever too.
I come here all the time every time I order pizza they tell me 30-35 mins which is long as it is and it usually ends up being 45-50mins. Always show up when they say it will be done and it's never done in time.......updating review 6 months later addingthis part decided to try them again ordered a large pepperoni and 12 wings the guy on phone told me that was a size order Icould get them when they ring me out the lady behind register says they only do 8 or 16 which do I want I said I wanted the 12 Iordered she wouldn't let me have that option even tho the guy taking order told me that was a size so I had to choose 8 shecouldn't have just charged me somewhere in between or given them to me for their mistake......I am definitely done with thislocation.
Full Menu
Pizza
Sandwiches
Salads
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-Code for the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 4.2 / 5 (560 reviews)Bbq Grill Casual American Pizza
Kniman Grill Inc
North CR 900 West 4766, 46392 Wheatfield, US
- ★ 4.2 / 5 (568 reviews)Breakfast Lunch American Cheese
Quiznos
W State Road 10 3840, 46392 Wheatfield, US
- ★ 4.3 / 5 (1206 reviews)Pizza Pasta Chicken Cheese Meat
Marcella's
County Road 1200 3854, 46392 Wheatfield, US