Full menu with prices & pictures
Primi Italian Steakh... 999 Montauk Hwy West Islip, NY 11795...
+16315269779
Reserve a table now for Primi Italian Steakh...
Here you can find the menu of Primi Italian Steakhouse in West Islip. At the moment, there are 57 menus and drinks on the menu.
Primi Italian Steakhouse, located on the South Shore of Long Island, offers a unique combination of authentic Italian cuisine and dry-aged prime steaks. The restaurant provides a variety of dining options, including an intimate private room with a fireplace, a main dining room with chandeliers and retro art design, a Lounge with a brick fireplace, and an outdoor Patio. The 18-seated Gally Bar is stocked with top liquors and features 2 flat screen TVs, while the Wine Cases showcase a selection of the world's best wines. Guests rave about our specialty dry-aged steaks and classic Italian dishes.
Primi offers a mix of positive and negative experiences from patrons. Despite past disappointments with overcooked steaks, the outstanding service and delicious cocktails were highlighted. However, some guests were unhappy with the lack of reservations on Sundays, slow service, and inconsistent quality of food. The lively atmosphere, friendly staff, and tasty seafood boil were praised, whilst some dishes, particularly the seafood options, fell short. Overall, the restaurant provided enjoyable experiences for birthday celebrations with excellent service and delicious food, but improvements in reservations, food quality, and speed of service were suggested for future visits.
Celebrated our friends 49th year. eating was amazing as usual.
Always a great time to eat. consistent and great specializations.
We've never been there, but we knew about friends who have it. my man and I celebrated our high...
Service was great! Food ran the spectrum. Caesar salad was bland , beef Wellington was very goo...
Service was slow. They took away beverages and never replaced them and never asked if another o...