Shell Shack - Tyler
Shell Shack
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Shell Shack in Tyler. At the moment, there are 19 dishes and drinks on the menu.
**Dining at The Shell Shack: A Mixed Bag of Experiences** The Shell Shack offers a varied dining experience, with highlights including excellent fried pickles and crispy calamari, alongside desserts like the fried bread pudding drizzled with caramel. However, patrons have noted inconsistent food quality, with some experiencing lukewarm or overcooked seafood. Service varies, with many praising attentive staff while others faced delays and insufficient responses to concerns. Pricing also sparked discontent, especially regarding surprising market rates for seafood. Despite the negatives, improvements in atmosphere and service suggest some diners might find a worthwhile meal, albeit with caution regarding costs and food preparation.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Shell Shack a mag?
This is our first visit back to the Shell Shack since it opened a few years ago, and what a lovely change! Our service was excellent, the food exceeded our expectations, and the atmosphere was comfortable and welcoming. The restaurant was busy, and while the staff was minimal, they worked hard to ensure everyone was well taken care of. I highly recommend paying them a visit! View all feedback.
What User dislikes about Shell Shack:
They have Blue Moon on tap and the best fried pickles! But our crab and shrimp came out luke warm and over cooked. The service was good though, thank you Kayla! We might try again, not sure. View all feedback.
Always great food here. Wait staff is awesome as well. This is a number 1 spot even though prices have gone up,
The tater tots are soo good Food is really good Bar is awesome and the oysters are big You should stop by and check it out
This is the best seafood I've ever had! The restaurant was spotlessly clean, and the service was incredibly attentive. I had a few questions about the menu, and the waiter patiently took the time to explain everything. He also made sure to keep an eye on our table. Our order was prepared perfectly and tasted amazing! It’s my favorite seafood restaurant in Tyler!
This is the first time I've ever given a restaurant a 1-star rating! DO NOT EAT HERE! I’m usually not one to complain and I typically focus on the positive, so let’s start with the good: the calamari was nice and crispy, though it could have used a bit more salt. However, I’m genuinely concerned that my husband might end up with food poisoning. He ordered oysters on the half shell, which arrived on a plate of ice but were at room temperature. He usually finishes every oyster, but he could only handle 6 this time. The boiled dish tasted overwhelmingly of chili powder and was overcooked by about 10 minutes, making it very difficult to peel. We managed to eat just one shrimp before deciding to leave. The total bill was $234.00! What a complete waste!
The food was so good. Be sure to try the fried Bread Pudding with caramel sauce as a dessert! It is a little expensive for the relaxed atmosphere, but we really enjoyed our visit.
Menu
Happy Endings
Fried Bread Pudding$8.2Gelati
Scoop Of Gelato$2.3Dessert
Homemade Carrot Cake$9.4Billy's Desserts
Ultimate Chocolate Cake$9.4Sandwiches
Half Pound Burger$16.5Seafood Plates
Catfish Plate$11.8
More information
QR-Code for the menu
Suggested nearby restaurants.
- ★ 3.5 / 5 (1018 reviews)Steak Italian Pizza Pasta Tea
Lago del Pino
Old Chandler Highway 14706, 75709-4914 Tyler, US
- ★ 4.5 / 5 (1221 reviews)Barbecue Venues Sandwiches Cheese
The Grove
3500 Old Jacksonville Hwy Tyler, TX 75701, 75701-85ND, United States
- ★ 4.6 / 5 (3096 reviews)#1 Vegetarian in Tyler
Roast Social Kitchen
1125 E 5th St Tyler, TX 75701, 75701-3317, United States