Full menu with prices & pictures
Gerardo’s Pizza Past... 800 Montauk Hwy, 11967, Shirley, Uni...
(+1)6313992700
Order food online for delivery
Reserve a table now for Gerardo’s Pizza Past...
There are also parking options for your vehicle, the next parking lot is Mastic-Shirley Station at a distance of 353 meters from Gerardo’s Pizza Pasta in Shirley, Or, you could take the public transportation and get off at the stop LIRR-Mastic Shirley, which is 428 meters away from Gerardo’s Pizza Pasta.
The restaurant from Shirley offers 20 different menus and drinks on the card at an average price of $9.0.
This restaurant has garnered a variety of opinions, showcasing both highlights and low points. While some diners rave about consistently delicious pizza and a welcoming atmosphere, others have encountered rude service and disappointing food quality. Issues like undercooked pizza and careless packaging have left some patrons dissatisfied. However, the owner’s friendliness and standout dishes like meatballs and pasta have encouraged return visits for many. With room for improvement in service and food preparation, this establishment remains a hit-or-miss option for local pizza lovers, but loyal customers continue to advocate for its potential.
What bob smith likes about Gerardo’s Pizza Pasta:
I have visited this restaurant twice now and each time the pizza has been consistently delicious. I have sampled a few different varieties and have always been impressed. The owner, Jerry, is a kind and welcoming man. The meatballs were particularly tasty and the sausage and peppers dish was also very good. I highly recommend this place. View all feedback.
What Jacqueline Mckenna doesn't like about Gerardo’s Pizza Pasta:
It might be a good idea to adjust your business hours. When customers come in at 11:23, even though it says you open at 11 and your door is open, they shouldn't be met with a rude employee. I am a frequent customer here, but if I continue to be treated this way, I will take my business elsewhere to a pizza place that deserves it. View all feedback.
It might be a good idea to adjust your business hours. When customers come in at 11:23, even th...
This pizza was not the best I've ever had, but it was still good.
I have visited this restaurant twice now and each time the pizza has been consistently deliciou...
We ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza. The pizza came to $26. I understand inflation and the p...
Great pizza. The regular looked amazing and it was. Every bite had that perfect crunch. Definit...
Garden Salad
Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, red onions, cucumbers, and black olives
Goat Cheese Walnut Salad